florida Date: 09-18-2025

Best 12 Diamond & Gold Jewelry Stores in Fort Myers, FL (part 3)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1James Avery Artisan Jewelry4125 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901
2Judys Jewelry & Antiques12710 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33919
3The Coin and Jewelry Exchange12680 McGregor Blvd Ste 4, Fort Myers, FL 33919
4Banter by Piercing Pagoda4125 Cleveland Ave KI-15, Fort Myers, FL 33901
5Darwins Jewelry4135 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916
6Bradleys Jewelers14261 S Tamiami Trl Suite 3, Fort Myers, FL 33912
7Pandora Jewelry4125 Cleveland Ave #1905, Fort Myers, FL 33901
8Spirit of the Earth2252 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901
9Quartz & Clover2281 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901
10Coral JewelersNW13 & NW15, 4135 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd Grand Pavillon, Fort Myers, FL 33916
11Gulfcoast Coin & Jewelry14181 S Tamiami Trl #110, Fort Myers, FL 33912
12Downtown Jewelry & Watch Company2125 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

1.James Avery Artisan Jewelry

Address: 4125 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901

(2) user ratings total:

Tori Rubio Super friendly and helpful.
5 /5

2.Judys Jewelry & Antiques

Address: 12710 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33919

(186) user ratings total:

Toni Granchi Judys jewelry was recommended to me from my jeweler. I had some coins and other articles for assessment. An appointment was made and the store is fabulous just like the owner Sal.He assessed all the coins which were not as many 50 cent pieces as I thought. he had cookies and candy wrapped as give a ways. i tried to buy a jewelry box which is perfect for my small items. He would take no money from me and gave me money for what i brought him. oh and when i entered the store I was greeted by the very friendly, kind staff. Go there folks ands see what items he has and also what he can do for you with items you may have.
5 /5

3.The Coin and Jewelry Exchange

Address: 12680 McGregor Blvd Ste 4, Fort Myers, FL 33919

(176) user ratings total:

paul cotter We were in the store 9/3 got a decent offer for our gold coin set but less than what we were willing to sell for. I will definitely make this my first stop when Im ready to sell
5 /5

4.Banter by Piercing Pagoda

Address: 4125 Cleveland Ave KI-15, Fort Myers, FL 33901

(144) user ratings total:

Virginia Brown Just got my seconds pierced today and Tiffany was fabulous!!! She also helped me pick out a few beautiful gifts for my daughters! Thanks again Tiffany!!
5 /5

5.Darwins Jewelry

Address: 4135 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916

(14) user ratings total:

arion788 Great goldsmith. I needed a gold herringbone bracelet resized. Mr. Darwin did a beautiful job (change is not noticeable). I would recommend him to anyone who has fine jewelry that needs repair or adjustment.
5 /5

6.Bradleys Jewelers

Address: 14261 S Tamiami Trl Suite 3, Fort Myers, FL 33912

(138) user ratings total:

alma mcauley Absolutely professional and delightful! I walked in with a Rolex watch that stopped working, Brad told me they stopped working on Rolex watches but that he was happy to check it out. He got it working again and on top of that he cleaned it for me. I went to them because of their background and great reviews, they are going to be my Jeweler for life, check them out!
5 /5

7.Pandora Jewelry

Address: 4125 Cleveland Ave #1905, Fort Myers, FL 33901

(137) user ratings total:

Giselle Ledezma I was shopping for a new ring with my niece (8years old). A sales associate was rude that made me leave without purchasing anything. My niece was very excited to open her new toy, and she dropped the receipt on the floor among with a small paper from the gift. The sales associate rudely told my niece to not be throwing trash on the floor. Although I don’t condone my nieces actions and I did ask my niece to pick up the trash, the sales associate could’ve been nicer in this situation and kindly asked my niece to pick up the trash.
1 /5

8.Spirit of the Earth

Address: 2252 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

(137) user ratings total:

Chloe Marum The two employees working at the shop near Harpoon Harry’s tonight were incredibly kind and helpful! They went above and beyond to answer all of our questions from mineral composition to spiritual uses and mythology of the crystals we were looking at. Thank you so much! We can’t wait to visit again :)
5 /5

9.Quartz & Clover

Address: 2281 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

(125) user ratings total:

Ann Marie Meadows Cute store. Lovely selection of bracelets and singing bowls and a few Hong drums as well. Small tems to add to your collections or get the perfect gift for someone. Will go back!
5 /5

10.Coral Jewelers

Address: NW13 & NW15, 4135 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd Grand Pavillon, Fort Myers, FL 33916

(11) user ratings total:

eloise king Excellent repairs by Eddy will make your damaged jewelry look new again. A master jeweler, he is such a meticulous craftsman that I trust him with family heirlooms. His unique and exquisite designs are stunning and I receive compliments on the amber and gold pendant he created for me every time I wear it. Having been a customer for over ten years, I know that he holds himself to the highest standards of workmanship. The owners integrity and courtesy make this business very special, it is a real "gem". It is always a pleasure just to stop by to admire the beautiful jewelry in their showcases. Do not be surprised to find a line of customers, most of them are prior clients who know that his superlative work is well worth waiting for!!
5 /5

11.Gulfcoast Coin & Jewelry

Address: 14181 S Tamiami Trl #110, Fort Myers, FL 33912

(109) user ratings total:

dan m Awesome place. When I walked in, I was greeted immediately and they saw that I had coins in my hand. The lady behind the counter instructed me to see the gentleman in the back. When I got there, I met Garrett. Garrett was very knowledgeable and actually taught me a couple things about coins that I didn’t know. He took the time to make sure that I was getting rid of everything that I wanted to and he was also giving me the right pricing for the items that I wanted to sell. After that, I dealt with Kathy, she was in charge of getting my check together for the items that I sold. Her light and bubbly attitude was definitely refreshing. I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking to sell any kind of gold silver or jewelry. The prices that they gave me for the things I sold were excellent and not cut 30% like a pawn shop would.
5 /5

12.Downtown Jewelry & Watch Company

Address: 2125 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

(101) user ratings total:

James Ackert I have used these folks to size an Omega watch bracelet and polish a nice Tissot watch with an 18k gold bezel. The bezel on the Tissot was scratched from a few years of wear, but Downtown Jewelry restored it LIKE NEW! The price has always been quite reasonable. Thanks so much, Downtown Jewelry & Watch!
5 /5