Best 13 Jewelry Stores Near You Sarasota, FL

Scott Stehman What an easy transaction. Quick reply to my questions even after business hours. Straight to the point. Shipped the watches immediately after payment. No BS. No Drama. And no hassle. About an easy of an internet transaction as you can have. I’m on the complete opposite coast and had no worries or problems. Alyona was a joy to work with. And most importantly the watches were awesome and even better than the pictures provided. Stunning vintage watches in great condition. I would have no hesitation buying another watch from Alyona and Cileone Jewlers. Super easy and fair prices.

Amy Stern I have always loved the beautiful jewelry at the Landing Company. Every piece is unique, and unlike anything you will find in other stores. Each piece is made to last - the quality is obvious. I purchased a necklace for my stepdaughter who just returned from Greece - she said the stone reminds her of the Mediterranean. I am anxious to return to the store soon to pick out a piece for myself! The staff is wonderful and attentive. They are kind, and care about making their customers happy.

Joe Doherty I recently purchased my Rolex from Mayors at UTC Sarasota, and I can honestly say it was one of the most pleasant and professional retail experiences I’ve ever had. From start to finish, the team made me feel genuinely valued — not just as a customer, but as a person. Melissa initially helped me begin the process and was incredibly knowledgeable, kind, and attentive. When I returned to finalize the purchase, John stepped in seamlessly. His professionalism and warmth made the entire experience feel effortless and enjoyable — he treated me with the kind of respect and sincerity that’s rare in retail today. I also had the pleasure of speaking with Anthony, their director, and the conversation we had was nothing short of awesome. His leadership clearly sets the tone for the team’s incredible customer service. You can tell this store runs on more than just sales — it runs on integrity, connection, and true appreciation for their clientele. Thank you again, Melissa, John, and Anthony, for making such a meaningful purchase feel even more special. You’ve got a customer — and a fan — for life.

PBB LLC Jeremy and Jennie are exceptional gemologists who exhibit remarkable patience, care, and consideration for others. They created an extraordinarily welcoming atmosphere during my experience, taking the necessary time to ensure that I felt my purchase was valued and significant.

Martha Mackey Love this jewelry store! Even tho the shop was busy, Jeremy took the time to greet. Several watches had new batteries put in within an hour! Jeremy showed me the great selection. I’ll be back for a purchase! Great place!

chilemeli Great service!! The best selection of jewelry in town. I found the perfect ring for me!!

Ron Droz Great store with a personal touch. Knowledgeable staff with the owner himself present daily.

Bernice Baroudi Amir is an outstanding jeweler. He has the knowledge, PATIENCE, and expertise to ensure your jewelry is exactly what you envisioned. Working with Amir was an amazing experience. He is full of ideas and gets the job done. I cannot speak his praises enough. He designed such a unique engagement ring for me and he is the only jeweler who understood what I wanted and MADE IT HAPPEN. Trust me, you cannot go wrong with Amir at Diamond Vault. Amir has a wonderful store and offers great customer service and the experience and talent to accomplish creating the most beautiful jewelry. I live an hour away from his store and I will only trust Amir with my pieces in the future. Other jewelers have seen my ring and have asked me who made it for me because it is of such quality and so unique. Amir uses the best materials and is very transparent with his pricing. THE BEST IN ALL OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA!!!

Max Armas Yam was very helpful and patient when picking out jewelry. They have a very wide selection for both men and women! I found and earrings, both sterling silver for a good price! 10/10 would recommend!

George My wife enjoys her bracelet

Susan Short Extremely polite and professional. They were excellent to work with. We used them for several appraisals on estate jewelry and were extremely impressed with their thorough estimates and excellent prices and service. They purchase jewelry at their location downtown Sarasota or do private consultatipn. Highly recommended.

Hannah Ranfranz Such beautiful & unique jewelry!

Sisti Michael A. (Mike) We have used this local, family-owned jewelry store over the years and have always found them to be honest and affordable, delivering quality products and outstanding repairs, all with a friendly, welcoming demeanor.