Best 13 Jewelry Stores Near You St. Augustine, FL

Haley Creamer Mandy was awesome in helping me find my necklace for my wedding and also helping my fiance with his necklace and bracelet. I loved Mandys personality and she was very friendly and talkative. She helped us figure out within our budget and let us see many options and wanted to go ahead and clean my ring while I was there. She provided awesome customer service! We will definitely travel back just to see her again.

James Adams I am so glad I Came across this shop in St Augustine Florida. The selection of Sterling Silver Jewelry this shop has in stock is to die for. If your looking for a Piece of Sterling Silver Jewelry with a specific gemstone set in it or some Symbol made of Sterling Silver this Shop has it. She is also one of the most knowledgeable people I have ever met about Gemstones, Minerals and different Rocks found in Mother Earth. If your Looking for it. Look Here. Really Good people running this Place. I have no doubt you will be taken care of and not disappointed.

Savannah Stokes I am so glad to have met Laurel who owns Anchor Boutique in St. Augustine! The moment I walked in, I felt like I had found something truly special. The jewelry here is beyond beautiful—so unique, coastal, and cool, but with an heirloom quality that makes every piece feel meaningful. I ended up picking out a piece that I absolutely love that was from her gemstone collection and having custom hand chains for me and my sister, and I’m honestly so excited to start my collection. It feels like the beginning of a new tradition- having these stunning, one-of-a-kind treasures that I know will stay in the family for generations. It’s rare to find jewelry that feels both stylish and sentimental and has a “cool girl” effect but Anchor Boutique has absolutely nailed it. I can’t wait to keep collecting. If you’re ever in St. Augustine and love jewelry with soul, don’t miss this place!

Beth Major I had an excellent experience at this jewelry store. The facility is stunning, with plenty of attentive staff available. My gold chain was repaired quickly and at a fair price. When I picked it up, I enjoyed a pleasant conversation with Cashmere, who was incredibly kind. I highly recommend this jeweler.

Szilvia Borbely I had an amazing experience at Olde City Jewerly & Pawn ! I brought in two old rings—a diamond ring with small diamonds and a simple white gold wedding band—and they offered me a fantastic trade-in value. I didn’t want to spend extra money, and they worked with me to make sure I could trade my old pieces for something I truly love. Thanks to their generous offer and fair pricing, I was able to get a stunning pair of diamond earrings and a beautiful white gold diamond ring. They were incredibly kind, patient, and helpful throughout the entire process, making sure I left 100% happy. I couldn’t be more satisfied with their service, pricing, and professionalism. If you’re looking for a jeweler who truly cares about their customers and offers amazing deals, this is the place to go! Highly recommend!

Tara Octaviano What a beautiful art gallery! Lots of coastal decor! Affordable and local artists.

Jeff moser Dan did an amazing job taking a mold of my vision turning my dads old gold ring into platinum. I dont wear gold and the diamond was from my great grandmothers engagement ring in the early turn of the 20th century that he had converted in the 80s. It sat in a jewelry box for almost 25 years since my Dads passing. Couldnt be happier with the outcome, now I can actually wear it.

Ramona Jaramillo I HIGHLY recommend Myers Jewelry & Gifts!!! I bought a ring several years ago for my husband and everyone quoted me $$$$ to get it sized, and I had given up. Randomly met him at another store and came by to trade the ring in - instead he was able to size it up and preserve the pattern and integrity. THANK YOU LENNY!!!

Susan M. Jannuzzi A Rare Gem in Every Way! JR Benet took care of everything for my warranty when I didnt actually purchase my piece at their store — making calls, handling the paperwork, and treating me with genuine kindness and professionalism throughout the process. Their customer service is truly exceptional! On top of that, their collection is absolutely stunning — the most beautiful and unusual pieces I’ve ever seen. If youre in St. Augustine, this place is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be returning as a customer!

Jeff Pinar This Brighton Store in the Outlet Mall always has some deeply discounted premium jewelry, purses and bags If you are visiting St Augustine, this is a must stop for quality gifts and presents for everyone on your shopping list. Many other outlet stores carry inferior products for their specials, never here. All the sales associates are knowledgeable and helpful Brighton girls! Love this store!

Anthony Bellino Our experience with Frank Reubel Jewelry in St. Augustine Florida was an all around A+ experience. We visited on vacation and popped in to browse, ultimately buying a gold chain and diamond ring. From our initial interaction with Inere, to later interactions with her and Anthony related to a repair request, the customer service was excellent. I highly recommend this shop. You won’t be disappointed!

Derek Scholz Went to the store just to window shop. Saw some items and needed different sizes. Fortunately Brelyn was a major help for us. She went above and beyond for us going back and forth from the back going on the ladder multiple times. Answering all our questions and was super knowledgeable about the store. Even recommended similar items when our sizes were not available. Also offered the fitting room. Would 100% shop at this Earthbound again especially if Brelyn was working. Really made the trip and we found a lot of new outfits.

Angela DiMauro 40+ years in business in itself should tell you something! I love this store, the owner and her staff. Her talent as a buyer for filling her store with treasures is amazing too! Go, revisit and find your treasure today! Aloha and Mahalo, Angie