Mellow Mushroom Fleming Island - Fleming Island (FL)

4 /5 James Sweet: Psychedelic-themed pizza restaurant. The food is good, but pricey. The crust on the pizza is good, but not great. One interesting thing was that they apparently have a liquor bar on the premises too, so this is really more of a weekend pizza hangout than a neighborhood pizza joint.

5 /5 Jeff Eng: Came in for dinner and got a Kosmic Karma pizza. It was a tasty hot and fresh soft dough pizza. Service is great, and my one year old was mezmorized by the decor. Its a little pricey, but the quality is there.

5 /5 Camila Vieira Kwak: Chloe is the best server! I had such a great experience during my visit! Our server was absolutely wonderful—attentive, friendly, and super quick with everything we needed. She checked on us at the perfect times, made great recommendations, and truly made the meal even better. The pizza was delicious, but her outstanding service is what really made the night special.

5 /5 Patrick Capps: I recently had the pleasure of being served by Kaylee (bartender) here, and she was absolutely outstanding. Her service was impeccable from the moment I sat down—attentive without being overbearing, quick with refills, and always checking in at just the right time. What stood out most was her attention to detail. She kept the bar spotless the entire time, wiping things down between guests and staying organized even during the busy rush. It made the whole experience feel cleaner, smoother, and more enjoyable. On top of that, her personality truly made the visit memorable. She was incredibly friendly, outgoing, and easy to talk to—one of those people who can brighten the atmosphere just by being herself. Her positive energy made the bar feel warm and welcoming. If you’re visiting the Fleming Island Mellow Mushroom, I highly recommend grabbing a seat at the bar and hopefully you will get Kaylee as your bartender. With service like hers, you’re guaranteed a great experience.

5 /5 Carly Rogers: Steph was phenomenal. Her service was the perfect blend of efficient, attentive, and personable. She remembers details, anticipates what you need before you even ask, and pours some of the best drinks we’ve had anywhere. Always has my order ready for me when I walk in. You can tell she genuinely cares about her customers and takes pride in her work. Her positive attitude made the atmosphere feel warm and inviting. People like Steph are rare, she’s the kind of bartender who elevates the entire experience. We’ll absolutely be coming back specifically because of her!