Sea Mario Italian Restaurant - Pompano Beach (FL)

5 /5 Samantha Rheel: We’re originally from NY and found this place through some locals and we’re so happy we did. Every year we come here when we’re visiting and the food is phenomenal. Mario and Nadia are so welcoming and friendly; the service is great. You can tell that Mario cooks from the heart, it’s authentic Italian food but he also puts his own twist on things and it’s amazing. We truly can’t praise Sea Mario enough and wish we were local to eat here all the time.

5 /5 loyda Glaser: We are Newyorkers who had been to this restaurant once in December 2024 and we had a guest with us this time that we thought for sure would enjoy the restaurant. Upon being seated, we were greeted by the owner/waitress who told us all the nightly specials with prices unknown. Being adventurous we tried the Lobster Bisque and the Yellowtail Snapper Arrabiatta: both were fabulous and worth the aggressively priced amounts. The other 2 parties ordered off the menu and were also very pleased with the quality and taste of the food. We just returned from Italy and surprisingly Sea Mario’s food tasted just as good (if not better) than many of our meals that we had on that trip, so if you’re looking for real home made fresh old school flavorful Italian cooking, this is the place for you. My only suggestion is to bring the bread to the table with the drinks and without having to request it.

5 /5 Meli Gee: Stepping into this restaurant feels like discovering a secret. Tucked away in an unassuming area, this restaurant is a true culinary gem, and the moment you cross the threshold, you are transported. The atmosphere is immediately inviting, romantic, and perfectly quaint, setting a magical stage for the meal to come. ​From start to finish, the service was outstanding, attentive without being intrusive, ensuring a smooth and delightful evening. ​The food, however, was the star of the show. We indulged in two signature dishes, both of which were absolutely outstanding. The Bucatini Nadia was a masterpiece—perfectly cooked pasta enveloped in a rich, savory sauce. It was clear every ingredient was fresh and prepared with care. The Chicken Parmesan was equally impressive; crispy on the outside, tender inside, and served with beautiful marinara. These dishes were the epitome of classic Italian comfort food executed flawlessly. ​The crowning highlight of the meal was the Hazelnut Gelato Affogato. The marriage of rich espresso and creamy, nutty hazelnut gelato was the perfect, decadent end to an incredible meal. ​Sea Mario is more than just a restaurant; its a genuine Italian experience. Outstanding food, outstanding service, and a beautiful atmosphere make this a must-visit. If you are looking for an authentic, high-quality Italian night out, look no further—this place is truly a treasure.

5 /5 Val Kalasowski: The best Italian restaurant in the USA location Pompano Beach! This is the best place for family dinner and for meeting with friends in Pompano Beach. We are in love with this place for almost 2 years. The freshest and most delicious desserts of Italian cuisine. The most delicious pasta of Italian and the most delicious lamb only in Pompano Beach in this restaurant.

5 /5 Brian Addeo: If you want fine Italian dining. This is your go to. Upscale only. If you’re cheap. Don’t go. The food was a 10/10. When the owner is the chef you know you’re in for some fire food. Our waiter was amazing. The whole service experience was amazing. We started off with a bottle of wine, the clams as an appetizer, and me and my girlfriend shared the seafood dish that had the linguini with clams , oysters, octopus, lobster, shrimp and calamari as the double dish (there’s a price for 2 people) and then for desert we got the homemade gelato with baileys and a shot of espresso choice. Sorry I am not good with the names. The bill came to around 200 without tip for 2 people. Was it worth it? Without a doubt. We will be back. If you’re looking for an amazing romantic setting to bring your special someone or family and you want true fine dining Italian cuisine. This is the spot. Thank you for such an amazing experience.