St. Augustine Seafood Company - St. Augustine (FL)

4 /5 Thomas Mertz: St. Augustine Seafood Company has a rustic atmosphere and spotty service but the food was fabulous. There is limited indoor seating but more outside. The bar is next door in a separate building so alcoholic drinks must be purchased separately. You order at the counter; the food is brought to the table and the staff bus the table. The four of us ordered conch fritters, peel & eat shrimp, cilantro slaw, and taco bowls. It was all good, although the fritters were very dark, almost burnt. (Had I been alone, I wouldve sent them back.) The shrimp was cooked in some sort of spiced brine that made them so delicious, I didnt bother with cocktail sauce. The main issue with the service is that they completely forgot my order and served everyone else. I had to go ask what was up, and even then they seemed confused, but finally came through with my meal.

2 /5 Noemi S.: Outrageously expensive for poor portions and long wait. The ppl at the counter and bussing around are nice, but the food for what it costs it’s not worth it for any reason. 22$ for a fish sandwich super small and poorly flavored with warm to cold french fries. Not so many places to eat in St Augustine city center so you end up eating here as it’s the only place that serves dinner on a medium-average ok quality, but this doesn’t really matter when you wanna eat good (the minimum at least!). We liked their lemonade. Place was extremely busy. Recommend book in advance or as soon as you get there for the night

5 /5 Fernando Alonso: St Augustine Seafood Company is a great place to enjoy fresh seafood with excellent service. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel very welcome. We had lunch in the beautiful backyard, which added a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere to the meal. A very nice spot to take your time, enjoy good food, and experience a pleasant setting.

5 /5 Raquel Oliva: Excellent food! We ordered shrimp and they were amazing—huge, flavorful, and beautifully presented. A real treat. The burgers were also very good. The only downside was that we came back at night hoping to hear live music, but no one was playing. Still, we really loved the patio area with the oak tree and lanterns—it gave such a cozy, charming vibe. Overall, a great spot and definitely worth visiting. St. Augustine Seafood Company

4 /5 Quaily Bug: Servers were very nice place was clean. We both had shrimp tacos, both grilled. We had one coleslaw with sauce on it on coleslaw without sauce on it. Excellent both of them the clam chowder New England style in my opinion it was more soup than instead of the thick and creamy, which is my preference but lots of clams and it did have good flavor.