19 Best Insurance Services in Pensacola, FL

Joe Lepo Rusty Messick and his excellent staff have been providing personal and competent auto and home insurance for our household for over 20 years. I am always able to reach either Rusty or one of his staff in a few minutes for the best instant advice Ive found anywhere.

Paul Holmes Angie has been very helpful and a pleasure to work with. She always is quick to respond and resolve any questions or services needed.

T Craig Blackmon Dont judge a business by its store front! A thrifty business owner is one who keeps overhead(costs) down and saves "us customers" money on monthly premiums...thats all I care about and Greg represents the same insurance companies as agents with billboards. Thanks man!

Dawn Garcia Greg Garcia was very professional. He fixed my car and Im very pleased. Highly recommend!

Elinor Regan-Smith Eddie Zarahn is one of the most decent, honest and professional persons I know. My folks used Zarahn Insurance both professionally and business wise almost my entire life. Some people say dont put all your eggs in one basket but if Zarahn Insurance is that basket... You and your property are in very capable and safe hands. Thanks Eddie for building a hometown company that still cares!

Chase Dupuis Zarahn Insurance Agency is one of the best insurance companies around! Our property management company has dozens of properties insured through this firm and we have nothing but great things to say about our experience with them. Shoutout to Jason and their whole team for making our jobs easier. We look forward to working with you all for many years to come!

Phillip Staton Prentice Smith at Direct Auto has been the most resourcful, kind, understanding, knowledgeable, and absolutely someone you want to speak with when you call in; or consider yourself lucky if you get him upon being transferred in. Call in with extension 20753 to get the best help you will receive

Patrick burton ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Highly Recommend Agent Prentice Smith! I had an outstanding experience working with Prentice Smith at Direct General Auto Insurance. From the moment we connected, he was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful. Prentice took the time to explain all of my coverage options clearly, answered every question I had with patience, and helped me find a policy that fit both my needs and budget. What really stood out was his friendly attitude and dedication to making the process easy and stress-free. Its rare to find someone who goes the extra mile like he does. If youre looking for someone who truly cares about getting you the right coverage, Prentice is the one to call. Thanks again for the excellent service!

Dorothy weber Jessica is super nice and so eager to help if you have questions or any concerns. She will get the answers you need and get back with you in a timely manner. She is very honest and will get you the best price on any kind of insurance you need. Give her a call!

Marvetta Nesbitt I have been with Key Insurance for over 40 years. They put their customers first and work to provide you with the best coverage and the best companies. Paul and Maggie have been incredible over the years, and my new agent, Jessica Haulotte has continued their professionalism and care. Call her and I promise you want be disappointed!

Callie Cerda I just love Extreme! I recommend any and everybody. Ask for Crystal!!! She is beyond amazing and I won’t ever go through anyone else. Crystal makes sure she can help you in any way possible for the best quote and is very well trusted. She makes you feel like a priority! Y’all I’m telling you, don’t shop no where else!!! Thank you for all you do Crystal.

Ryan Taylor This company is truly the only company anyone should use. Do not file online, do not call any other agent. Out of the 10 years I’ve had insurance this is the only company I’ve ever used that actually tries to get their customers the best discount! Also shout out to Danielle for going above and beyond to make it happen.

Lin Williams I just bought a new policy for my car with Jake McClelland at State Farm. He was an awesome individual to work with. Very personable and knowledgeable. I will definitely be sending his name to my friends if they need car insurance or anything else. He was wonderful.

Letrice Mos-buckles Super Outstanding Experience! I had a truly outstanding experience. Michelle was incredibly attentive—she made me feel safe and secure, which was a big change from what I was used to. From making sure I had a car, to getting insurance and feeling confident on the road, she handled everything with care. Fisher was also amazing—super helpful with all my questions. Together, they make a powerful team. Their unity and showmanship really stood out, and they got the job done! Will you should be proud of the team weve build.

Myra Mercedes Gamez How about i call and This man with an accent hangs up on my face twice then puts the phone on do not disturb so i continue getting a voicemail because i asked to speak to an agent or someone in sales because i had a customer looking to buy insurance !!! I do not know what kind of place this is but just speaking to whoever it was he SAID his name was dan but who knows i can just imagine how they treat other customers if he just treated me like that ! Update I called later to complain about him... And a woman answered she said its only her and the OWNER there and his name is NOT DAN. so he owns that place and treats possible customers like that. Lies about his name to avoid possible embarrassment. I worked for sandy sansing and was trying to get insurance for my customers and they were looking for car and house insurance unfortunately these people are crooks probably not even licensed seeking individuals who have little to know options to bury them in Dept and lies. Do not give your business to this place for your own sake people in car city complain about them all the time and they sure will be going out of business soon with the way they do things.

Angela Brown Tyson WARNING WARNING!!!!! Rude and unpleasant call locating a Agent that CLAIMED he worked at this location. Person answering the phone kept hanging up on me when I tried to explain the situation, she wouldnt respond and remained silent on the phone and kept hanging up until I called back and the ANDREW answered the phone and presented himself as someone else. Could hardly hear the person from the start of the call she was whispering not sure what SCAM WE GOTTEN OURSELVES INTO, VERY UNPROFESSIONAL AND RUDE TO CONTINUE TO HANG UP AND WOULDNT GET A SUPERVISOR ON THE PHONE!!!!!

Damien Lamb My company has used Rushing Insurance for our commercial lines the past 10 years. We have been completely satisfied with the courteous and professional service we received. Kudos to Cindy Ritchie who has been our go-to RI contact. Cindy has continuously surpassed out our already high expectations. I recommend Rushing Insurance highly.

B N Rushing Insurance has been a great partner for years, helping insure our rental properties. They can get really creative with insurance coverage and they go above and beyond when needed. My latest building was a difficult one to find an insurance product for and they came through with a solution the same day. Very happy customer.

Phyllis Trimuar Southern insurance has had our account for several years. They are very helpful and courteous. Chris tends to whatever might be needed in a very timely fashion. I switched over my home insurance to his company and my boss also did. Comes back with some very good rates.

MC Equipment Services LLC I would highly recommend Southern-Insurance Services for anyone looking for a local agent. Derek and Chris have been excellent through the entire process of insuring my new company. I cant thank them enough and if I could give more stars in this review I would.

Marcia Keyes I had a very professional experience and would recommend her to anyone searching for reasonable car or home insurance she rent the extra mile to make sure that everything was done timely and saved me quite a bit of money

Tasha Robinson Leslie was thorough, knowledgeable, and quick with responding back with a quote. She got me and my daughter a great premium and saved us hundreds of dollars. Highly recommend her if youre looking for all things insurance!

Hector Javier Rocafort It was a great experience to have a consultation with Sylvia Ramos. She was very professional and helpful.

Reydel Hernandez Excellent agent, speaks #Spanish in #pensacola to help with #floridablue

Genevieve Gallagher Ms. Pulos is the sweetest, kindest woman. She will work hard to get you the best quote possible. I highly recommend.

Villa Gebbie It takes time before you get in touch with them via phone. Difficult to do business with them. Office is close most of the time...I cannot blame them. They are still afraid of covid-19...

Deloris Bedgood I can’t say enough good things about this insurance company. From the moment I contacted them, I was met with kindness, professionalism, and a genuine willingness to help. Their team is incredibly knowledgeable and experienced — they walked me through every step, answered all my questions clearly, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. What truly sets them apart is how much they care. They don’t just "get the job done" — they go above and beyond to make sure everything is handled properly and efficiently. You can tell they’re passionate about what they do and truly value their clients. If youre looking for an insurance company that combines expertise with compassion, look no further. Highly recommended!

Julie Rogers Amazing customer service! John is the best! He saved me $31 a month on my auto insurance. All I had to do was stop by and sign paperwork.He helped me with my homeowners policy. He helped my Dad get his homeowners policy started back after it lapsed months ago & got a reduced price for his auto insurance. I’m sending other family members to him. Regina, his assistant is super sweet. John & Regina are the real deal.

Carrie Chatham We have been with Kite Insurance Agency for 3 years now and they have been amazing to work with. Mary is the best. She is very detail oriented and very professional. She is prompt in returning phone calls and emails. She worked hard to get us the best rate before I even asked. Definitely recommend them!

randy buckel Kite insurance has been insuring my business for nearly 20 years. Mary is always available for renewals, certificate, builders risk and any questions I have. Recently my wife was having issues insuring an equine osteopathy school and Mary was able to get her insured when lots of others couldn’t.

Heather Martin Great group of people. They worked hard to explain all the we needed and got us covered! We appreciate the hard work the staff at Madril insurance provided us as a new business!

Kathleen Moran They are simply the best! Always thinking of what we may need even before we do. When I compared prices with other agencys; they were much less. I love them!

Tom Coxon I was dreading getting new home owners insurance after my previous company jack my premium through the roof. Ashley made the experience effortless and saved me a ton of money. She explained all my questions easily giving me a few options to choose from. I couldnt me more pleased with my experience, literally let their office with a big smile on my face. Thank you so much again to Ashley and Great Florida Insurance for making the process effortless. I will be recommending her to all my family and friends for their future insurance needs.

Cindy Daniels We would like to thank Ashley Stephens with helping us with our Home Owners Insurance Policy . Ashley was very helpful and compassionate on every detail. She answered all of our questions and went above and beyond to get things done . We Highly recommend Ashley Stephens at Great Florida Insurance in Pensacola Florida !

TJ Prime The wife of the owner of this insurance company is one of the most disrespectful people Ive ever spoken to. Seem very And convenienced when speaking with me.

CE Jones They just helped my mom-in-law save over $3K on her homeowners insurance (pre 2002 built). She was over-insured in some areas of coverage. They were so nice and patient with her. Thank you so much for everything!

Jason A James Westmark was super helpful! He got me the best quote for my new Home Owners Insurance policy and was easy to understand and communicate with. If youre looking for insurance, this is the man who will have your back and find you the best deal possible!

Rhonda Snell I’ve had an outstanding experience working with Amy for my automobile insurance needs. From the very beginning, she was knowledgeable, patient, and incredibly responsive. She took the time to explain all my coverage options clearly, helped me find the best policy for my budget, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. What really sets Amy apart is her commitment to customer service. She’s always quick to respond to questions or concerns, and she genuinely cares about making sure you’re protected and fully informed.