19 Best Insurance Services in Sarasota, FL

Joan I have been with Atlas Insurance for about 35 years. They always go above and beyond to find the best policies. The agents are very helpful and always return my calls and emails promptly. I highly recommend.

Suzette Stravinos I recently obtained condo insurance with Atlas and dealt over the phone with a couple young ladies who were competent, very helpful and knowledgeable as well as experienced agents. I’m extremely pleased with their service and will continue my coverage as well as car insurance with this company. They go out of their way to get you the lowest rates with the best coverage.

Sean F Blue Circle is awesome. I used them for homeowners insurance and recently added professional and general liability for my business. Brook is very professional but also incredibly friendly and makes it a very stress free process.

REM I’ve had a truly wonderful experience working with both Brook and Pam at Blue Circle Insurance. When other insurance agents told me they couldn’t help me, Brook gave me multiple options. I know that when I call; I will either speak to someone directly or get a prompt call back if I have to leave a voicemail. Email response is rapid as well. I feel very blessed to have been referred to them by someone else. HIGHLY recommend going with Blue Circle!

Angie Kaplan While in the process of purchasing a new home, we had to obtain homeowners insurance so that we could meet the mortgage requirements prior to our closing. My sister recommended Joyce Jackson/We Insure Sarasota. I contacted Joyce and Im happy to report that she made the whole process go smoothly. We are happy with the insurance rates, and we would highly recommend this agency.

Frederick J Miller Jr In response to an email blast from our agent about shopping auto policies I asked her to do exactly that. I didn’t have any expectation because I thought my policy was already very good and affordable. To my pleasant surprise with apples to apples coverage she found us a great policy with a top rated company and a significant savings of $1,100 per year on two cars. That’s huge! In less than 24 hours with just two phone calls and two emails we had switched to the new company and I never had to leave my living room. I felt like we had received concierge level service from Joyce Jackson and couldn’t be happier. My wife and I put the mobile app on our devices and now we have every detail about our policies at our fingertips. What could be better or easier? Believe me, not every insurance agent treats their clients this way. I highly recommend Joyce Jackson at WeInsure on Clark Road in Sarasota. You can’t do better!

David Kaplan Jose was very responsive to my questions regarding my change over to an annual escrowed insurance payment from direct semi-annual payments. This required that he arrange to refund an extra direct payment that I had made right before the escrowed payment was made by my bank. Jose very easy to work with and very personable.

Maestro Fishman My name is Michael ducks dad I was pleasantly helped by Pablo and Walter in making adjustments to my policy. Unfortunately I have suffered a stroke and was barely able to articulate my needs. They were kind understanding and extremely helpful and eventually able to provide me the service that I needed. Pass off to your corporation my sincere thanks and appreciation in this matter. I give them the highest ratings possible

Michael Bello My experience with your company has been absolutely disgraceful. The treatment toward Hispanic clients is unacceptable, and the Spanish-speaking service was completely unprofessional and disrespectful. It is shameful that in this day and age, such disregard and lack of respect still exist. Your staff is clearly untrained and lacks even the most basic sense of customer service. The disorganization, arrogant attitudes, and complete lack of empathy make this one of the worst service experiences I’ve ever had. And let’s not even talk about the outrageous, unclear estimates—a total lack of transparency that only creates more mistrust. Instead of offering support, your company adds to people’s stress and frustration. You seriously need to clean house from the ground up, because what you currently offer is not a service—it’s an insult. Extremely disappointed. I absolutely do not recommend your business.

hebah Abu obaid The service is very bad. I was in an accident exactly a month ago. A woman hit me with my car, so I called the insurance company a whole month ago. They always refer me to a woman named Bridget, so I send her a voice message to no avail. No one calls me back, and my husband also calls them a lot with no avail. I wish icould give u zero stars

ESTELA SANTIAGO HERNANDEZ I had to file a claim and the claims process with this agency was excellent. The adjuster was very attentive and took care of everything quickly. They made sure I was well taken care of through every step.

Itzayana Pérez I was impressed by how this agency helped me reduce cost on my insurance without compromising on quality.

Paulette Loe I love your Milewise program! It fits my lifestyle perfectly! I have two homes… one north and one south with a car at each place. I drive very little and never at night. It is a perfect fit!

Roberto Cozzi Just wanted to thank Maurice for the excellent support I received from him as an Allstate agent His follow up attention to detail are a joy to experience Not only did he respond to a voicemail request with a hard copy of response by email - He also called up to make sure I received the email Outstanding support

Kevin Stone I have had a policy with Arne Carlson Insurance for many years now, and have been completely satisfied from day one. Ken Patten has always given me immediate attention for any and all matters.

Kay Stone Andy Carlson is professional, always helpful and a great asset to the community. As an independent agent, he is able to find the right insurance at the right price! Thank you, Andy.

Ravi Patel Vince did a great job with procuring us great insurance coverage for a rental property of ours. So much so that we decided to use him for our personal residence as well. He and his team make it a very easy and stress free process for shopping rates and coverage. I could not ask for a more professional and better agent than Vince.

Leah S I have been with Vince (at Ideal Insurance) for longer than I would like to admit, but I’ve also never been disappointed! Thank you for always looking out for our family and advocating for the best rates and coverage. I appreciate your hard work, honesty, integrity, and professionalism. If you are looking for insurance coverage or simply want to discuss your options, I highly recommend you give Vince a call at Ideal Insurance.

Sheri Mozina Could not be more impressed with Dave Albero. He had contacted me via Linkedin a few months back asking if Id be interested in a quote for insurance. At the time, I was not shopping auto insurance as my current policy did not renew for months. Fast forward, my policy was up for renewal. Contacted Dave within a day, he is saving me alittle over $400 with a top insurance company. Anna Albero was fabulous as well finishing up all the details with me. Very professional, friendly and Ill be sending more people their way!

D Dyas Dave and Anna are an incredible team! I can’t say enough great things about them. With a major move to Florida coming up faster than we realized they came through quickly with the coverage we needed—at a great price. Their efficiency, professionalism, and support made all the difference!

Kristina Sargent, Esq Melissa is amazing and always a pleasure to work with. She will answer all of your questions and really works with you to get the best insurance packages. She goes into detail with explaining the process and is extremely helpful with navigating all the available options so you get the coverage you actually need. I recommend her to all of my family and friends.

Cassie Friedman Have had great experience with Melissa. If she doesnt know the answer to your insurance question, she knows someone who does, and she is full of advice for getting the best coverage while not hurting the pocket too much. I appreciate her advice on my workers comp!

Blanton Girls Mom Paul knows insurance and makes getting a plan a simple process. Love that he goes above and beyond for his clients! Having a personal agent in health insurance gives peace of mind and Paul is the best. He’s an expert and passionate about his work and really cares about his clients.

Bradley Santore Paul was very transparent in showing me all of my options and made the process very easy for me. Highly recommend to anyone looking to save money on their insurance plan while also getting better coverage in the process!

C Aaron, and Leslie, Are the BEST insurance agents I have ever know. They actually care about me and our needs. They are very kind,helpful, and friendly . I highly recommend them.

Happy Nurse Aaron has saved me a significant amount of money multiple times when I needed insurance. Everyone that I have sent to A& M Insurance has been very happy with Aaron and his team as well. Thanks so much!

Jayca Smith Andrew diligently searched for insurance that met my needs. Throughout the process, I was impressed by the representative’s professionalism and patience. I highly recommend Millennium Insurance to anyone seeking an efficient and caring insurance agent!

Jonathan Miller Rachel was quite fast at getting me a quote! I so appreciate her prompt attention to all the details I specified also! Very good to work with! Thank you.

Richard Frattura I have known and worked with Bronya for over 10 years and her level of service, care, professionalism, and dedication to her customers is unmatched! Insurance buying can be a painful experience but working with Bronya, she makes it fun, pleasant and you will understand exactly what coverages and service you can expect. She will always exceed your expectations & I strongly recommend you give her a call for all of your insurance needs. You will not be disappointed!!!!

Amanda Wade Bronya is the most reliable insurance person I have ever worked with. I was sad to see her move as I have been with her for over 20 years. She covered all facets of insurance for me from personal auto and home, to commercial coverage on rental buildings , multiple business liabilities, commercial auto and contractor liability . We have a complex insurance portfolio and she was always very through so that nothing was missed. I would recommend her to everyone in North Carolina - as I had recommended her to everyone I knew here in PA.

Debbie Driscoll Highly recommend Dakkak Insurance to everyone ... and I have. I have passed along three new customers. They are helpful & very knowledgeable. They will offer you your options and always have your best interest in mind.

MaryTee Miller I was in an accident Wednesday Aug 6th due to someone running a red light. My car was totaled. Called Allstate at the accident scene. From then on each department involved has called, texted and emailed several times a day to keep me abreast on the process. Last night Aug 12th, my lender had been paid off and remainder put in my checking account. WOW, very impressive. Thank you Dakkak insurance and the rest of the Allstate team.

Jamie Henry Glen is the absolute best insurance individual I have ever dealt with - very kind, listened to what we required, and did his very best to locate the coverage we required. Glen always responded rapidly with answers to my questions and took the time to really listen to what we were looking for in coverage. I would more than suggest his company. Thank you again!

Jeffrey Dorn Danielle S has been instrumental in helping me achieve my insurance needs when I recently moved to Florida. She is fantastic, responsive and great with her communication skills. She is very experienced in all aspects of consumer insurance services and saved me a ton of money, over 50% of what I was quoted for the exact same auto coverage from multiple other brokers and direct insurers. I would not hesitate to recommend her and will continue to use her and the Insurance Man for my insurance needs. Finally found someone that is not condescending and not a gas lighter, and truly cares about the client! Keep up the great work Danielle!

Heidi Marino Julio was soooooo helpful. Polite, respectful and patient. Just great. Fast, fair and easy. I’d definitely recommend him.

stephany morales Marlene was such a great help! I recommend her!

Johnathan Van Houten Do not use Smith Insurance. Like many others, Cathie dropped the ball (ignored my requests) several times over the years, but none so bad as this last. I moved, and exercised diligence in letting them know ahead of time. I filed with them April 29 for a May 9th closing date. I sent them the cancellation form they asked me to fill out and received word from Cathie herself that they had what they needed. I received an email from the actual Insurance carrier on May 3rd, but was assured by Cathie it was an automated email, and I had nothing to worry about. I even stated I did not want to have to deal with this after I sold. Here we are in August, and I received a note from the Insurance company of non-payment. it seems Cathie never bothered cancelling the policy, despite the fact I no longer own the house or even live in Florida. I called Smith Insurance, they put me on hold, and then hang up on me. When I try to call right back, its just after 5, so they dont bother answering. Unprofessional, but what else can you expect. Now I am dealing directly with the insurance company because I cannot trust Smith Insurance to do anything. Added 13 Aug: The very next day I called the actual insurance carrier and got it all worked out myself. And get this, Cathie Smith from Smith Insurance sends me a new policy declaration for the house I no longer own, they neglected to cancel after multiple communications, and the subject of our call the very previous day.

Keith Faris Alexis at Smith Insurance Group has been SO helpful in finding me the best insurance for my property. She has always been responsive, and has given me straight answers to tough questions. I have extreme confidence in her, and her agency. In order to obtain the best insurance, you must work with an insurance broker, not a captive agent. I highly recommend Alexis and Smith Insurance Group!