Barefoot Bills Island Grill - St. Augustine (FL)

4 /5 Bob M: Barefoot Bill’s Island Grill is a hidden gem! The burgers are absolutely stand-out—juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. If you’re a burger lover, this is your spot. The staff is incredibly nice and helpful, making the experience even better. The atmosphere is a little unique since it’s tucked away at the end of an indoor shopping alley, but that adds to its charm. Plus, there are lots of TVs, so it’s a great place to catch a game while enjoying your meal. It’s also a bit off the water, which made it easier to get in during a busy day—no long waits, just great food. Oh, and did I mention the burgers? Seriously, they’re worth the trip!

2 /5 Eduardo Araujo: Server was great, very nice and welcoming. I got the beef nachos, worst nachos I have ever had, taste was like it came straight from a can. I got the hurricane burger and my wife got the calypso burger, both patties burned. Ou, we also got plastic silverware and plates

5 /5 Amelia Chilling: Forgot to write this review because my friend and I were tipsy and had just been to a funeral and life is hard- this is for September. Let me tell you: Tamika was the best waitress ever. My friend and I ordered two baskets of mozzarella sticks. Zero judgement from Tamika. In fact, she thought it was funny and shared plenty of laughs with us. The cheese? Superb, and laid on cabbage to separate the oil. Genius. 100/10 experience. Tamika if you still work here, you’re my favorite server of all time and you deserve a raise. Much love! Also the floor was clean which was awesome considering it was in the evening downtown. If you know you know!

5 /5 H. Jesse (merple-serple): Staff are always considerate, offering you what you need before you know you need it! Id ordered the Calypso Burger, extra mayo, and the waitress handed me more napkins before I could get embarrassed, haha. Speaking of, the burger was absolutely killer. Juicy, tall, usually I cant stand eating them but I absolutely had to try it. And it knocked it out of the park! Was eating like a caveman by the fourth bite, and Ill absolutely be back for another one soon enough. If youre in the area, its a reliable, fairly priced choice for a quick meal. Gets busy later on at night, though, so if youre hungry, get on line quick.

1 /5 Christine Butler: Worse “food ever”. Nobody ate their food. They liost the original order . Waited an additional 55 minutes for the liost. order. Overcharged even after a small discount. DO NOT EAT here unless you enjoy food poisoning. Manager Danielle was worthless