Beauti USA place

Keywords: insurance_agency,point_of_interest,establishment

GreatFlorida Insurance - Beau Barry - St. Augustine (FL)

Address: 🏡 2820 U.S. Rte 1, St. Augustine, FL 32086

Phone : +1 (904) 584-1166

Weekly Open time

Place GG: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJf1RXaTyd5ogRI_bfrhdoXN8

Where is GreatFlorida Insurance - Beau Barry 🏡?
2820 U.S. Rte 1, St. Augustine, FL 32086
What is the phone number GreatFlorida Insurance - Beau Barry 📱?
(904) 584-1166
What Clients Are Saying about GreatFlorida Insurance - Beau Barry (on GG)

5 /5 Jennifer Gamble: I highly recommend Amy Nuttall for home and car insurance. She saved me over $1,000 a year on my home owner’s insurance and hundreds of dollars on my car insurance. She is friendly, dependable and responds promptly with any questions I may have. Choose Great Florida and Amy Nuttall in St. Augustine!

5 /5 Micheline B: As my insurance premium was going through the roof, Amy has been determined to find a more reasonable carrier, and she did, half the premium I was paying. Great Florida Insurance has your back, and is best.

5 /5 David Wohl: Agent, Amy Nuttall, is very pleasant and professional. She expeditiously researched and executed a suitable insurance policy for my home. She returned calls promptly and answered all questions clearly and precisely. This is the type of agent I respect and like to do business with.

5 /5 Dawn Wynn: I had been with the same insurance company for 25 years before switching. Amy’s customer service is above the rest always a prompt answer, sometime responding on her own time. Appreciate her and all the guidance she has given along with the money I save.

5 /5 Annette Kidder: Amy Nuttall is the best! She is friendly, professional, efficient, and provides helpful feedback. We are very happy with our new insurance and would recommend Amy to our friends and family!
Convenient Location
GG map: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJf1RXaTyd5ogRI_bfrhdoXN8

Others Near St. Augustine,FL

19 Best Insurance Services in Pensacola, FL:Our Top 20 Picks

08-2025 GreatFlorida Insurance - Beau Barry in 19 Best Insurance Services in Pensacola, FL:Our Top 20 Picks

Your Florida Insurance Agency LLC - St. Augustine

Eric Emmons: I have no confidence in Michael Mayer as a Farmers Insurance agent or his business practices. His office changed my dwelling coverage from 700k to 545k without letting me know or asking if I would like a change in coverage. His office acted liked they were saving me money but my premium was basically the same with less coverage. I specifically asked his office staff if there was a change in coverage and they said "no" which was a lie. I brought my concerns to him thru email and he responded with a generic reply like I didnt understand how home insurance works. I need a specific amount of dwelling coverage due to the uniqueness of my home, but not once did he offer to ask questions or inquire about why I needed a certain amount of coverage instead unilaterally decreased my coverage without letting me know. If I didnt catch it and had a claim I would be S.O.L. I called farmers corporate and they were appalled with the specifics of my situation. The agent took time to ask why I needed that amount of coverage and thru documentation Farmers insured me for more than 700k dwelling coverage in case of a loss. I switched agents because Farmers is not to blame, Michael Mayer is. I would give zero stars if I could. Stay away!!!!!

Britni Burkins: Allstate Insurance - St. Augustine

Linda and Peter Dytrych: We switched over to Allstate as our premiums had been skyrocketing with our former insurance company. We are not people that want the cheapest insurance nor the cheapest coverages, for sure. We are just looking for fair pricing and an insurance company that will have our best interests and needs. Honestly, we have just purchased an insurance policy for 2 cars, our condo, and umbrella coverage. We sat down with Melissa Whiting and she is wonderful to work with; integrity, fairness, and honesty. Offered us coffee or water, even. Truly a breath of fresh air for the insurance industry. We are just new clients so we cannot comment on how the company will handle any claims. We love the location here in St. Augustine at Nix Boat Yard Road. Beautiful office; all renovated! We are saving about $1,600; we did reduce our umbrella coverage, yet still a very nice lower premium. Allstate offers 6 months only for auto insurance; for condo and umbrella, a full 12 month policy.

Knox Insurance Network - St. Augustine

Bluewater Erosion Specialists: James Knox is the Best of the Best! We have been a client of his since 1992 insuring all of our business and personal property. His vast knowledge of the insurance network refines the policy to fit each scenario. Its One-And-Done with Knox Insurance Network!

AAA St. Augustine Insurance and Travel - St. Augustine

Dinda Walter (Walt): Robin, at.the front desk was patient and kind. She went out of her way to map out our trip to Alaska by RV. We really appreciate everything that AAA has done to meet our needs.

Beck Agency - St. Augustine

Rina McCullough: Our experience with Melanie was great! She was quick, very knowledgeable, and found the best rate for our home insurance. We can highly recommend working with her!

Beaver Insurance Agency - St. Augustine

Misty Morgan: What a great experience with an insurance agency. While we were getting our new car we had talked with Dave and his guys about our current policy. To my surprise, not only was I paying too much but the policy I had really wasn’t what I needed. Dave and his guys put me together a quote the saved me over a thousand dollars annually. And the best part was I was able to understand all the coverages I have. So I just had them figure me a policy for my home and guess what??? They saved me again! Keep up the great work and thank you for taking the time to make sure I understood everything. Beaver Toyota customer for life!

Twin Palms Insurance Group, The Ward Agency - St. Augustine

Matt Nichols: Allyson is amazing. Her customer service is second to none. I have worked with many insurance professionals, and she is definitely one of the best I have had the pleasure of working with.

Kim Vona Insurance Agency - St. Augustine

Raymond: Kim tirelessly seeks the best coverage for the lowest price. She is very responsive to any questions or claims while maintaining a cheery disposition. One of the best agents I have known in 60 plus years. Highly recommended.

Craig Dewhurst - State Farm Insurance Agent - St. Augustine

Susan Amon: I recently had the pleasure of working with an exceptional State Farm insurance agent Vinny, who helped us secure a homeowners insurance policy, and I can’t recommend him highly enough. From start to finish, he demonstrated professionalism, expertise, and genuine care for our needs. He took the time to thoroughly assess our situation, ensuring we got a policy with more comprehensive coverage than we previously had, all while reducing our premium cost. His attention to detail and ability to explain complex terms in a clear approachable way made the process seamless and stress free. What truly stood out was his dedication to his clients-He listened to our concerns, answered every question promptly and went above and beyond to tailor a plan that gave us peace of mind. If you’re looking for an insurance agent who combines professionalism with the personal touch, this state farm representative is the one to trust!

Luis Vienrich: Allstate Insurance - St. Augustine

Amoy Guthrie: Called in several time to cancel my policy and on two attempts as soon as I mention cancel policy the call ended. Called back in to my local office and Ivette Reyes was able to turn my unfavorable experience into a positive one. She also acknowledged me as a long-standing client and asked about my reason for leaving. Thanks for your help as i do not like to leave unfavorable review. :)