Top 10 Rated Jeweler in Winter Park, FL (part 2)

Natalie Scalise I loved the beautiful earrings! So well made snd the design was exquisite.

Savannah Afu Super friendly and helpful staff. I got a customized bracelet and it’s absolutely adorable. The sterling silver is very nice but it does scratch easily so be careful.

caroline clark I would recommend Almut and her team to anyone who wants to create a bespoke ring. Not only is her jewelry beautiful, but the entire process from start to finish is enjoyable. She always has her clients best interest in mind, and truly helps to create a special/memorable piece.

Ry Tt This business is the real deal. Daniel is by far a top professional and very knowledgeable about precious metals ,diamonds etc . Made me feel very important as a customer. He paid ,in my opinion top price for my items. Would recommend highly to anyone.!! Thankyou again Daniel

Paul If you need jewelry appraised and/or have a jewelry stash of questionable valuable, Reynolds and Co. Jewelers is the place to go! I spoke to twelve stores who review and appraise jewelry in the central Florida area and decided on Reynolds and Co. due to their substantial experience with all types of jewelry, having a graduate gemologist onsite and very reasonable rates. Owner David spent a significant amount of time with us reviewing our jewelry. David provided insights on each piece and was very patient answering our many questions. At our request David provided candid recommendations and was never pushy to make a sale or steer us in a disadvantageous direction. Susan expertly performed appraisals on a number of pieces generating a document containing pictures, detailed information and a value assessment of each. Susan’s highly comprehensive analysis identified unknown information on a few of the pieces, ironically never noted in previous appraisals from other stores. Reynolds and Co. also sized two rings (expertly matching an intricate design so one could never tell!) and made a highly creative suggestion combining parts from two of our pieces with exceptional results. Thank you David and Susan, you are a blessing!

Anna Ferrer “Exceptional one-of-a-kind pieces! Joan Giles’ store offers an array of stunning, unique jewelry in a prime location on Park Ave in Winter Park. The craftsmanship is outstanding, each piece radiating beauty and individuality. Joan’s commitment to guaranteeing her creations adds an extra layer of confidence. Highly recommend shopping here for exquisite, one of a kind fashionable pieces.” Love this place and so glad she is finally in a store front, come check her out for yourself, you won’t be disappointed!

Hometownselects If I was to sum up the experience in two words cheap and insulted. We tested this place out because they have another place in Pine Hills it was my fault I told my wife to get a price on the inheritance that was dumped in my lap, family passing away is never fun anyway. But we have been selling on eBay for over a decade by now so I dont know why I told her to do it I guess just to test the waters so to speak. Anyway I gave her half and she went to the Pine Hills place and they offered $2000 she called me I said no, we both went to this old man who was sucking on something the whole time that was obnoxious! but an 1 1/2 hours later he says $755 I kindly let my wife handle it. She said your other store said $2000 he said for what and called them in front of her insulting her intelligence because he owns both stores and tells them not to do it. Well we politely left and sold half on eBay 3 days later for $3800 and its sad people have to part with their personal belongings just to have some rude gutless greedy man strip them of their dignity and profit off their personal private collection of memories. I didnt do it and I dont suggest you do it either, I know who bought my stuff and they wear it love it and appreciate the things that once graced my familys neck, fingers, ECT. Some jewelry is priceless and irreplaceable and this old man is drawing a social security check and doesnt need your money so dont give him the pleasure of stripping you of your dignity and pride for way, way less than its worth. "Your" worth way more no matter what $5-$500 will get. God bless and good luck! Oh this last part was for the unsuspecting customer not for the business owner. P. S. I posted the absolute truth I did not exaggerate, we made more money that I put down but we didnt take this old man all we had because again I was testing the waters. Ive dealt with these people before and they couldnt even tell you what Aqua Gina is because they arent about the business theyre about the money (period) oh I mentioned it he said what?... I was thinking, end of discussion!

Darci Carlton Lauren Sigman is my absolute favorite jeweler and jewelry store! Not only is she a fabulous human being, she is so incredibly creative! She has helped me reimagine many old pieces in my collection and has turned them into fabulous current, unique masterpieces! She has such vision and style. I love everything she has created for me! AND there isn’t a single visit to her shop where I didn’t walk out with something fun and fab from her retail collection! There is no such thing as stopping by for a few minutes, a visit to the store turns into the perfect shopping afternoon and I never leave empty handed! Run, don’t walk!