florida Date: 08-31-2025

19 Best Insurance Services in Gainesville, FL

AgentcyAddress
1Joshua T Hill - Aflac Insurance Agent4424 NW 13th St # C5, Gainesville, FL 32609
2Arnold Insurance4210 NW 37th Pl Suite 500, Gainesville, FL 32608
3G. Bradley Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance1410 NW 13th St Ste 9, Gainesville, FL 32601
4Tish Oleksy - State Farm Insurance Agent6021 NW 1st Pl, Gainesville, FL 32607
5Hummingbird Insurance Gainesville FL9145 SW 49th Pl, Gainesville, FL 32608
6Insight Insurance Group747 SW 2nd Ave STE 160, Gainesville, FL 32601
7Dan Shaw - Farm Bureau Insurance5001 NW 27th Ct, Gainesville, FL 32606
8Cottons All Lines Insurance, Inc.1222 NW 16th Ave, Gainesville, FL 32601
9Mitchell Burgess - State Farm Insurance Agent3909 Newberry Rd STE A, Gainesville, FL 32607
10Harbor and Associates Insurance2226 NW 8 Ct, Gainesville, FL 32609
11Bill Matchell - State Farm Insurance Agent140 NW 75 Dr suite a, Gainesville, FL 32607
12Kris and Associates Insurance, Inc.: Allstate Insurance3720 NW 43rd St Ste 100, Gainesville, FL 32606
13Jennifer Dubose4400 NW 23rd Ave Ste B, Gainesville, FL 32606
14GEICO Insurance Agent3080 SW Archer Rd suite 10, Gainesville, FL 32608
15Gregory Bradley: Allstate Insurance1410 NW 13th St Ste 9, Gainesville, FL 32601
16Flood Insurance5700 SW 34th St #402b, Gainesville, FL 32608
17Donna Mann - State Farm Insurance Agent2622 NW 43rd St STE A2, Gainesville, FL 32606
18Acceptance Insurance1126 N Main St, Gainesville, FL 32601
19Walter Agency420 NW 39th Ave, Gainesville, FL 32609

1.Joshua T Hill - Aflac Insurance Agent

Address: 4424 NW 13th St # C5, Gainesville, FL 32609

(5) Clients Are Saying about:

Dylan They do their best to guide you. If you dont succeed, its because you didnt do your part, or you pulled out too early. If they say do 25, do 50 always. If you dont know what this means, you will, and once you get it, youll do just fine. Wouldve kept working here if I hadnt caught a virus that almost killed me. (Also not their fault)
5 /5
Carolyn Seufert I never write reviews, however, I wish to say that, everyone at Aflac is great at what they do. The moment you walk in, you get a familiar feeling to home. Whether by the comfy furniture and refreshments provided, or the excellent customer service they provide. If you have comments and concerns with anything they will treat you like family. You can always expect #1 quality service, even better than Publix!
5 /5

2.Arnold Insurance

Address: 4210 NW 37th Pl Suite 500, Gainesville, FL 32608

images Arnold Insurance

(5) Clients Are Saying about:

Rebecca Yale Erica and angie are rockstars that will go above and beyond to work in your best interest for home owners insurance. They have come thru for me time and again to get me the best possible premiums for my needs. Recently my premium went up. I was upset but after talking with Erica she worked her magic and got my premium lowered but still have the essential coverage needed. You cant go wrong with Arnold insurance!
5 /5
Anna James Arnold Insurance seeks out the best home owners insurance at the best price for you! Thank you so much!
5 /5

3.G. Bradley Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance

Address: 1410 NW 13th St Ste 9, Gainesville, FL 32601

(47) Clients Are Saying about:

Kelly Oliveros Im so thankful for the interactions I had with Lilah! She was incredibly kind, understanding, and helpful. She took the time to really explain all kinds of insurance policy details to me and make sure I understood everything. She was totally approachable, made the process of getting quotes easy, took time to explain all kinds of important details, and was fantastic. I am so appreciative of the time and effort she put into working with us!
5 /5
Jean Thomas Korina was really helpful. She found a good home insurance policy for me and stayed in touch until it was complete. Im especially thankful for her effort!
5 /5

4.Tish Oleksy - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 6021 NW 1st Pl, Gainesville, FL 32607

(466) Clients Are Saying about:

Phoebe Shaw Erin was amazing to work with! She made everything quick and easy, and took the time to explain things clearly. I felt totally taken care of and confident in my coverage. Highly recommend!
5 /5
Lori Lazarus I have always found the folks at this State Farm to be helpful. Maddie is another great member of the team. I called with some questions about my policy and she was extremely helpful. If she didn’t have an answer she found someone in the office to provide the info and then got back to me. After I completed my transaction, I had an email confirming all we had done. Really helpful and came across as sincerely interested in helping me.
4 /5

5.Hummingbird Insurance Gainesville FL

Address: 9145 SW 49th Pl, Gainesville, FL 32608

(43) Clients Are Saying about:

Maja Potocki Rachel was the best! I have surgery coming up and she took time to talk me through all the different plans and helped me pick the best one for my needs. She was very patient through all my questions and offered great knowledge of the plans and wonderful advice. She gave me her direct number and email so I can stay in touch as more questions come up. Thanks Rachel!
5 /5
Shirley Bavonese My representative Cyvele was very helpful, patient and knowledgeable about the medical insurances I was deciding on. She took her time to explain and I never felt rushed. She was ever so personable and made the complicated process manageable.
5 /5

6.Insight Insurance Group

Address: 747 SW 2nd Ave STE 160, Gainesville, FL 32601

(41) Clients Are Saying about:

Dana Clayton Chris Floyd and Insight Insurance are amazing! Chris set up our Medicare Coverage for both myself and my husband. Medicare is a maze and you should not try and navigate it without a professional you can trust! I highly recommend Chris Floyd!
5 /5
Kay Kuhne Chris is amazing! He made the entire Medicare process easy to understand; not a small feat! He did all the research to narrow down the insurance plans that best suited my needs. He explained the pros and cons of several plans so all I had to do was choose one. He is a lifesaver!
5 /5

7.Dan Shaw - Farm Bureau Insurance

Address: 5001 NW 27th Ct, Gainesville, FL 32606

(40) Clients Are Saying about:

Jaclyn Moore I reached out to Dan just simply because he is in the area and had great reviews. His level of service made working with him easy! I’d recommend him to anyone looking for insurance. He’s great with follow-up, easy to reach, and quick to respond. Any questions you have, do not go under answered. He’s honest, thorough, and INCREDIBLE to work with! FOLLOW UP: Dan is the MAN! He saved the day when I needed it most. I’m buying a new home and it came down to the wire. Another company declined my application and Dan literally saved the day! Dan was able to get me approved and paperwork signed within 1hr of a call from me. I’m SO excited to work with and be insured with Dan. He’s passionate about his work and it shows. He is personable and fun to work with!
5 /5
Diana Roman Dan Shaw is a phenomenal individual, and I struggle to articulate his impressive qualities in words. Regardless of the time of day, be it late at night, early in the morning, or even on weekends, he has consistently been accessible or promptly returned my messages. Without a doubt, he is the ideal choice! His quotes are the best youll find!!
5 /5

8.Cottons All Lines Insurance, Inc.

Address: 1222 NW 16th Ave, Gainesville, FL 32601

(389) Clients Are Saying about:

Gabi Cruz Mike was able to get me set up on the marketplace for health insurance which was a huge help! I have since switched my auto policy to his agency as well.
5 /5
Hoai Vo My family receives great consultation from David and Mike. They are very patient and they always prioritize our wants and needs. We receive the most suited insurance plan each year, and the application process goes smoothly all thanks to their expertise. My family has been able to take care of their health all thanks to them.
5 /5

9.Mitchell Burgess - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 3909 Newberry Rd STE A, Gainesville, FL 32607

images Mitchell Burgess - State Farm Insurance Agent

(383) Clients Are Saying about:

Shedd Mark (Avenger60) Isaiah has been amazing and has helped a great deal to adjust our insurance policies and save us money wherever possible. Very professional and knowledgeable. Thank you.
5 /5
Abigail Hubbard I had a great experience working with Isaiah to switch my auto insurance policy. He made the entire process simple and stress-free. Isaiah was easy to talk to on the phone - kind, patient, and really took the time to explain everything clearly. He found me a reasonable rate, and I never felt rushed or pressured. Buying auto insurance can be overwhelming, but Isaiah made it feel easy. Highly recommend working with him!
5 /5

10.Harbor and Associates Insurance

Address: 2226 NW 8 Ct, Gainesville, FL 32609

(38) Clients Are Saying about:

Red They saved me $170 a month. I appreciate that.
4 /5
Alijah Babbs Have been with them for years. They’re like family at this point. Always great and easy to work with. If you’re in need of insurance and want white glove service go here! 10/10
5 /5

11.Bill Matchell - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 140 NW 75 Dr suite a, Gainesville, FL 32607

(310) Clients Are Saying about:

Xuan Dieu Vo Karla Kirkland has given us the best experience we could ever ask for when trying to obtain house and flood insurance. If you need insurance please please make sure you ask for Karla! She is so responsive and has answers to all of our questions in such a timely manner. She takes care of you like you are one of her own family members. We are actively in the process of trying to buy a house and needed certain insurance paperwork and Karla took matters into her own hands and emailed our loan agent directly and continued to correspond with them until the matter was resolved. She treats her job as more than as a job and I wish there were more people like her in the insurance industry and in the world! I cannot recommend Karla Kirkland enough! Please ask for her!
5 /5
Joshua I had the pleasure of meeting with Ms. Karla, the Office Manager at State Farm in Gainesville, Florida, along with Jessica, Lizbeth, and Ms. Debbie. During our meeting, we discussed the range of services we offer through ServiceMaster, including mold mitigation, fire restoration, water restoration, and other general restoration solutions that may benefit their State Farm clients. Additionally, I introduced our professional cleaning services, both commercial and residential. Ms. Karla, Jessica, Lizbeth, and Ms. Debbie were all a pleasure to speak with—professional, welcoming, and engaged throughout our conversation. I would highly recommend their State Farm agency to anyone in the Gainesville area seeking quality insurance services.
5 /5

12.Kris and Associates Insurance, Inc.: Allstate Insurance

Address: 3720 NW 43rd St Ste 100, Gainesville, FL 32606

(31) Clients Are Saying about:

Tram Do Just as other people have said, once you cancel the policy with them, they would make it difficult on you. I had been back and forth with the people at this company without a clear answer and they just said i am no longer their customer, meaning they dont care. Just be careful when you have to cancel your policy with them
1 /5
Shernee Bellamy-Fults While doing a change of agent, I had the pleasure of speaking with Virginia! She was very personable, called my company to verify all the steps and forms we’d need. She also was nice enough just to listen as to why I needed a new agent and what I was trying to do moving forward with a homeowners grant! She was so knowledgeable about it all and I’m very thankful for her expertise in how I could save on home insurance. Im looking forward to having these agents and a local company over who I have now.
5 /5

13.Jennifer Dubose

Address: 4400 NW 23rd Ave Ste B, Gainesville, FL 32606

(30) Clients Are Saying about:

B. Dan Wood I chose Ms. Dubose because she is with Farmers. She agreed to work with me. Ms. Dubose knew that I was closing on a home by a particular date and asked for the inspection reports. I provided them. She repeatedly asked for my current policy information and finally acknowledged receiving it. Then, she said that she forgot that I needed insurance on closing on our home. She frequently did not remember that I was a potential customer. She frequently did not answer emails or return phone calls. When I was able to contact her, she gave me the run-around on rates. I asked her to follow up on why my rate ended up being so high. She said she would check on it for me. I never heard back from her, even though I called the office and they said she would return my call. Ive moved on to a more responsive and efficient agent. I dont recommend this one to anyone who reads this post.
1 /5
Linda Goldman Very rude, abrasive and unprofessional. Felt like I had to chase her down to talk with her and she always seemed to be reluctant and bothered to have to answer policy questions or explain why my quote, for the same insurance company, increased by hundreds of dollars in just a few days. Never felt like my concerns were answered or considered to be valid. Went with another insurance company that is very friendly, always available to talk to, willing to answer and explain any policy questions I might have and made the whole process quick, easy and as pleasant as buying insurance could be.
1 /5

14.GEICO Insurance Agent

Address: 3080 SW Archer Rd suite 10, Gainesville, FL 32608

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Mary Bryant I think its sad that a big name insurance company like this doesnt have a phone number for their older patrons, you dont really know how to deal with websites...
1 /5
Andrea Davis Customer service over the phone is absolutely awful. Smh.
1 /5

15.Gregory Bradley: Allstate Insurance

Address: 1410 NW 13th St Ste 9, Gainesville, FL 32601

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Kelly Dulli I have had a fantastic experience with this insurance company. My agent, Lilah Griffis, has been so incredibly helpful and knowledgeable through this entire process. We were in a time crunch to get our homeowners insurance in place in order to close on a house, and Lilah made everything go very smoothly. I would definitely recommend this agency to anyone in the Gainesville area looking for insurance.
5 /5

16.Flood Insurance

Address: 5700 SW 34th St #402b, Gainesville, FL 32608

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Phil Pavarini Jr If you need flood insurance, this is the place to go. As an agent for nearly two decades, I cant remember any other broker, MGA or program administrator as responsive and helpful as these folks, Sarah, Krissy & everyone at TFIA. Thanks for the great service.
5 /5
Bill Langusch I had questions about my flood insurance which were answered promptly
4 /5

17.Donna Mann - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 2622 NW 43rd St STE A2, Gainesville, FL 32606

(26) Clients Are Saying about:

Iris Sarabia So far working with Barbara Forest on my insurance needs has been a wonderful experience. She is super friendly, easy to communicate with and most of all an experienced knowledgeable professional. Thank you for providing your help with my insurance needs.
5 /5
Arleen Wolf I am so grateful to Barbara Forest for her kindness and expertise. She has made all of our familys transactions (especially this past difficult year) go smoothly. Thank you, Barbara, for being so caring and gracious.
5 /5

18.Acceptance Insurance

Address: 1126 N Main St, Gainesville, FL 32601

images Acceptance Insurance

(259) Clients Are Saying about:

Gisselle Quiroga Called in regards to see if i could find a cheaper car insurance. Cecilia Jackson made signing up for car insurance way easier than I expected! She made me feel very comfortable speaking with her and she found me the very best rate! Extremely helpful and very easy to talk too. I will be recommending to my friends!
5 /5
Matthew Groezinger Shelby was the best insurance agent I’ve ever dealt with. She was extremely professional and very personable. Insurance can be a frustrating experience and communicating with her definitely lowered my cortisol and raised my faith in humanity. Wish I could give more stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
5 /5

19.Walter Agency

Address: 420 NW 39th Ave, Gainesville, FL 32609

(22) Clients Are Saying about:

Q Chang If the system allows me to leave O start I will do it, but I need to leave at least 1 start before I can submit my review here. I hope all the words from me to give guild, idea and expression about the service from this agent and his team. Please do homework, be smart and be wise before you want to do any business with this agent and his team. I got a quote from this agent and bought the insurance to my family-owned company. I was told I need to pay at least $100 to get the insurance to be active and effective after I had paid for a insurance. I was unhappy by this dishonest activity and unprofessional endeavor, so I called the agent who gave me the quote and helped me on the purchase. The agent told me a quote is just a quote which does not mean anything. I have to pay extra to get this policy to be of protection on my company. I paid the extra to this office because I already did business with this office and spent my time on it. The total amount I paid was much higher than other offers from different insurance companies offered to me. The first encounter with this agent was in 2017. The agent and his office was trying to play the same game for the year of 2018. They wanted to add more extra on the amount I paid in 2017. I was annoyed, shamed and shocked by the trick. I called this agent office, canceled this insurance policy, and asked them to return the balance for this policy in March, 2018. I had been contacting this office several times for the refund. Every time they told me they are going to contact me for the refund. I did not receive any phone calls and no mention of the refund. Please call me or refund me. I hope I shared my experience with this agent office here to give other potential customers alert and head-up. If you really need an insurance for your properties or companies, please be wise before you have any connection with this agent or the office.
1 /5
Heidi Strater purchased home insurance last year. I set up a payment plan. I called this month to find out how to renew the insurance .I was told by my agent Erin Frederick that the plan had been cancelled in March for lack of payment. She went on to say that a cancellation notice was sent to me and they never heard back. I do understand that it is MY responsibility to make sure the bill is paid I would expect that an agent might make a call or leave a message that they didnt receive payment. I searched my email and never received a cancelation notice. I did receive many emails advertising their services and thanking me for being a customer. (I guess they also didnt know I was no longer a customer.)I never received a letter in the mail. Erin did ask if I wanted to pay for another policy for the coming year. I would have to pay the balance in full since my records show a lapse in coverage. Ummmm no thanks . I do understand that they probably didnt make a lot of money with my patronage but maybe someone will read this and decide they better go with another agency.
1 /5