19 Best Insurance Services in St. Augustine, FL

Raymond Kim tirelessly seeks the best coverage for the lowest price. She is very responsive to any questions or claims while maintaining a cheery disposition. One of the best agents I have known in 60 plus years. Highly recommended.

Ronald Kearns She was GREAT! Very helpful, we did our home owners/ automotive and golf cart. She found us extremely coverage at a great rates Anyone we talk to we recommend her and if they don’t already use they should switch to her.

Susan Amon I recently had the pleasure of working with an exceptional State Farm insurance agent Vinny, who helped us secure a homeowners insurance policy, and I can’t recommend him highly enough. From start to finish, he demonstrated professionalism, expertise, and genuine care for our needs. He took the time to thoroughly assess our situation, ensuring we got a policy with more comprehensive coverage than we previously had, all while reducing our premium cost. His attention to detail and ability to explain complex terms in a clear approachable way made the process seamless and stress free. What truly stood out was his dedication to his clients-He listened to our concerns, answered every question promptly and went above and beyond to tailor a plan that gave us peace of mind. If you’re looking for an insurance agent who combines professionalism with the personal touch, this state farm representative is the one to trust!

Stephen Moles We recently moved to Florida and was most fortunate to find a great State Farm agent close by our home. Craig Dewhurst has been wonderful and we would like to highlight Brian in his office who always goes the extra distance to make sure we have the best coverage at a competitive price. Thank you Brian for your extra efforts and thank you Craig for employing good people with high standards! Steve M.

Elizabeth C Nico and Lindsay go above and beyond to help you find the coverage that is right for you. They are very knowledgeable and easy to talk to. They walked us through our policy so we would know exactly what we were getting and how we could use it. 10/10

Monica Antigua I can’t say enough good things about Nico! When I was working a job that didn’t offer insurance, I was overwhelmed trying to find coverage—especially with kids who had ongoing health issues that needed attention. Nico went above and beyond to help me. He took the time to understand my situation and worked hard to find an insurance plan that not only met our healthcare needs but also fit within my financial budget. Thanks to him, my kids were able to get the care they needed without breaking the bank. He was kind, patient, and truly cared about helping our family. Highly recommend!

Eric Emmons I have no confidence in Michael Mayer as a Farmers Insurance agent or his business practices. His office changed my dwelling coverage from 700k to 545k without letting me know or asking if I would like a change in coverage. His office acted liked they were saving me money but my premium was basically the same with less coverage. I specifically asked his office staff if there was a change in coverage and they said "no" which was a lie. I brought my concerns to him thru email and he responded with a generic reply like I didnt understand how home insurance works. I need a specific amount of dwelling coverage due to the uniqueness of my home, but not once did he offer to ask questions or inquire about why I needed a certain amount of coverage instead unilaterally decreased my coverage without letting me know. If I didnt catch it and had a claim I would be S.O.L. I called farmers corporate and they were appalled with the specifics of my situation. The agent took time to ask why I needed that amount of coverage and thru documentation Farmers insured me for more than 700k dwelling coverage in case of a loss. I switched agents because Farmers is not to blame, Michael Mayer is. I would give zero stars if I could. Stay away!!!!!

Bill G Sandra Arruda was an absolute gem to deal with. She was the first to provide a quote that could beat USAA. She quickly delivered all required documents so our closing date did not get delayed. Sandra is a real pro!

Jeanne Ryan State Farm is the best! I have been a customer ever since I can remember and I have always been pleased with their service. I can call anytime and Mary and Aretha are always very patient in helping me with my needs and questions. I love being able to get on the phone and get immediate assistance with people that I have known for a long time and they know me. Nice being able to put a name and a face together. Very personal service!

Adam Peter FANOS This Morning Jennifer contacted me to see if I was satisfied with my policy at Perry UnWalla agency. I had a couple of minor concerns with my policy. One she could not fix yet but will check. The other she was able to lower my premium by correcting my mileage that I drive. It was a pleasant experience and conversation with her. I appreciate she told me she is working from home and is in Alabama. I liked the personal touch of her experience and professionalism. To be able to talk with a human person over the phone to talk about my insurance questions is very refreshing in today’s world of AI. Thank you for a wonderful conversation.

Gil Harris Scott and his team are the greatest. I went with Gilliland Insurance Group with my homeowners insurance for my new construction home In Sept 2020. Scott is very responsive and just a good all around agent. He made sure I had the best deal available for my situation, and also made sure I understood every part of my police answering all my questions thoroughly. So it was a no brainer to give him a call when my auto insurance policy was up for renewal to see if he could do better than what I had, and sure enough Scott came through again with more coverage at a cheaper rate than I was paying. If youre looking for a one stop shop for insurance coverage, trust me when I say Gilliland Insurance Group is in a class of their own, and I highly recommend them.

Gmail Email Great experience working with Jennifer! Our homeowners insurance increased by $1000 so we decided it was time to shop around. Jennifer found us a new policy with better coverage & saved us the $1000. Since we needed a new homeowners policy we decided to see if we could find savings on our truck, motorcycle & umbrella policies. Jennifer found us new policies with great companies & saved us another $800. Thank you so much!

Sarah Duffy-Smith Lisa with Brightway has been amazing!…plus saved us just over $600! Couldn’t be an easier process!!! Please consider getting a quote—totally worth it! ❤️

Nicole King Ms. Lisa was incredibly helpful and knowledgeable in getting me set up with affordable car insurance. As this is my first year paying, I had a lot of questions, and she walked me through everything with patience and clarity. She even explained different plan options that could help me save on my biannual payments, something I wouldn’t have known without her. Lisa was instrumental in the whole process, and I’m so grateful for her support. Highly recommend working with her if you’re looking for someone who truly knows their stuff!

Melania Atzori Visited this office today and left very happy. They were able to answer all my questions, and made sure that my needs were met. I left feeling very confident that I was in excellent hands.

Heather Bell Christopher was easy to work with. He made switching over easy. He was able to help me navigate my insurance needs and appreciated he patience with me during the switch.

Gary Ondrey Pablo and Shellie are a real pleasure to work with. Calls are always answered or returned in a very timely fashion, and time lines always respected. Very friendly company to work with and they make sure that my coverage is adequate and appropriate. I have been with this company for almost 15 years. They exemplify outstanding Customer Service. I highly recommend Whitco Insurance!

Phillip Brunson Pablo and his wife, Shellie are highly responsive and communicate frequently any updates needed including preparation outline for hurricane season. Of all my searches for a broker for our vessel insurance, their great reputation was confirmed by my very favorable experiences.

Bluewater Erosion Specialists James Knox is the Best of the Best! We have been a client of his since 1992 insuring all of our business and personal property. His vast knowledge of the insurance network refines the policy to fit each scenario. Its One-And-Done with Knox Insurance Network!

Meridith Beach 20 years with a great company! Agent is always available and fights relentlessly for you and what you deserve; anything from a house burning down to a car accident! Knox Insurance is a one stop shop for all your needs! I highly recommend this company to anyone and everyone!

Rina McCullough Our experience with Melanie was great! She was quick, very knowledgeable, and found the best rate for our home insurance. We can highly recommend working with her!

Marco Stiner David has shown creativity in his solutions for my personal and business insurance needs....definately NOT just another agent!

Rod Gillmore Our neighbor recommended Christy Lawrenson who proved to be a delightful person to work with...and she found a great hazard (hurricane) policy for our condo. By combining it with a new condo homeowners policy, (at a lower price than what we had been paying for homeowners insurance) the total cost for both policies was less than $100 more than we had been paying for our homeowners policy alone. Amazing! She also found auto insurance for our vehicles at a considerably lower cost. Nice savings! Were very grateful to have her as our new insurance agent. Shes definitely a knowledgeable professional who listens and delivers!

Isabel Martig I just moved to Florida from across the country and needed to change my car insurance policy to this state. My fiance put me in contact with Christy L., she called me right away & was able to give me a few different good options for my updated policy. Within less than an hour I had updated insurance with no headache involved! She is very knowledgeable, personable, and helpful. Thank you Christy, it makes a huge difference to have one less thing to stress about through this process of moving across the country!

Carla Street Coqui Insurance team and Wanda are absolutely fantastic. Experienced and very thorough! You will not regret it!!!

William Cunkle Coqui insurance is the best! I worked with Wanda and she helped me through every step, explaining everything in detail. I would highly recommend Coqui Insurance!!!

C G All went good until we had to cancel our insurance. What we were told on the phone when canceling was the wrong information and waited for a check for over a month, then we found out that Brook Miles never notified Federal National. We had to do everything on our own. Thanks for nothing!

Lee Alycia Knowles My experience has been great! The staff is very friendly and helpful.

Stephen Brouhard Was familiar with Mike Rhodes from my time as a residential home inspector. When I needed coverage for my boat and auto detailing business I chose Mike and was not disappointed. He is very knowledgeable of industry and brokerage requirements and did due diligence finding an affordable general liability quote which is typically challenging to do. Thank you!

MerMan Pressure Washing Mike was unbelievable to work with. He was patient, informative, knowledgeable, kind, and beyond helpful in finding me the best business insurance. Mike always answered my questions in great detail and in a timely manner. I will always use Rhodes Insurance Agency in the future and recommend him to others.

Matt Nichols Allyson is amazing. Her customer service is second to none. I have worked with many insurance professionals, and she is definitely one of the best I have had the pleasure of working with.

Ottó Konyhai I got the contact of Allyson from my friend and colleague because I needed a general liability insurance policy in a very hazardous industry. She got me one so quick I almost couldn’t keep up with her phase (all in a positive way). She was professional and very informative. I 100% recommend her to anyone who is searching for great insurance deals. Thank you for your help, Otto

Connie Hansen A very knowledgeable and friendly insurance agency. Super nice people who take the time to make sure that you get what you need at the best price. I had a problem with a policy (something I accidently did) and Samantha fixed it quickly and very professionally. Many thanks!

S Edwards Thank you Leigh Insurance Agency for being so helpful! Sammie jumped right on my request when I asked for a quote. Everyone in the office is very kind and professional. I highly recommend Leigh Insurance Agency to my friends, colleagues and clients!

Denise Brightway’s Anastasia “Stacy” Ryan Agency Owner/Principal at 2801 N 3rd Street Unit B St. Augustine is always there advocating for us, helping us find the right insurance each year as well as helping solving various homeowners renewal issues. Below is a pix of one of my magnolia blooms in appreciation for this insurance company. Thank you again!!

Anabel Morales Stacy, my sales agent was so awesome. Help me get through this to make things easier and was always available to me.

Tyler Phelps The team at The Hobbs Agency was amazing. They really took the time to work with me to insure my business had the right amount of coverage. Phillip and Sarah were absolute rockstars. I highly recommend them for any business owners out there!

Steve Giovanni After working for Florida Power & Light for over 30 years my father-in-law recently retired, and while transitioning to a fixed income mode reviewed all of his household expenditures including home insurance. Not only did Dave provide him with prompt, courteous, and professional service, but he also was able to save over six hundred dollars per year on homeowner’s insurance. This is a significant savings for anyone, especially those relying on fixed income. I was extremely impressed with Dave and his staff and pleased with the number and quality of options provided. I highly recommend contacting him to see for yourself what he can do for you.