Beauti USA place

Keywords: insurance_agency,point_of_interest,establishment

Oldest City Insurance - St. Augustine (FL)

Address: 🏡 212 San Marco Ave Suite D, St. Augustine, FL 32084

Phone : +1 (904) 824-7283

Weekly Open time

Place GG: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJTUp4Yckn5IgRRv9W856l2Os

Where is Oldest City Insurance 🏡?
212 San Marco Ave Suite D, St. Augustine, FL 32084
What is the phone number Oldest City Insurance 📱?
(904) 824-7283
What Clients Are Saying about Oldest City Insurance (on GG)

5 /5 Kloy Mayberry: Excellent customer service! Getting auto insurance has never been easier. Britney (if I am spelling correctly) made the entire process super easy and took less than twenty minutes. Helped me save $400 on insurance. Great and friendly staff!

5 /5 Danielle: Awesome customer service. They got me a great deal and helped me save an extra $100.00 a month. Very friendly and knowledgeable, I definitely recommend them.

5 /5 Jaryn Perez: This was the most amazing experience I’ve legitimately ever had, Mark, Kerri, Brittany was the kindest, intelligent person I’ve talked to all day more than willing to explain questions I had that the 6 different DMV’s I called couldn’t answer he spent hours with me on the phone more than willing to give me the best quote possible I went from having to pay 600-267 great person helped me figure out I wanna be an auto insurance agent, gave me the licensing details and all go to them for any question, concern and they will help you fully, more than the DMV literally couldn’t recommend them enough.

5 /5 Dew McDonald: Best Insurance Company I have ever done business with. Mark is very professional, courteous and finds the insurance you need. This family owned business makes you feel like family. Have questions, just ask. They always have time to answer questions and don’t make you feel ignorant. Highly recommend this Company.

2 /5 Derek Sands: Edit: 02/28/2024. Spoke to a Mark via phone after using the websites contact form while shopping for insurance unrelated to the previous attempt over a year ago (see below). Very pleasant and professional. Said he would follow up this afternoon. Looking forward to it. Edit: He never followed up. Went elsewhere for insurance. Previous review: Stopped by the location during the business hours posted on Google but was closed and no hours posted. Called the number listed online and the number just rang.
Convenient Location
GG map: https://www.google.com/maps/place/?q=place_id:ChIJTUp4Yckn5IgRRv9W856l2Os

Others Near St. Augustine,FL

12 Recommended Insurance Agencies in St. Augustine, FL

08-2025 Oldest City Insurance in 12 Recommended Insurance Agencies in St. Augustine, FL

Brightway Insurance, St. Augustine - St. Augustine

Denise: Brightway’s Anastasia “Stacy” Ryan Agency Owner/Principal at 2801 N 3rd Street Unit B St. Augustine is always there advocating for us, helping us find the right insurance each year as well as helping solving various homeowners renewal issues. Below is a pix of one of my magnolia blooms in appreciation for this insurance company. Thank you again!!

Old Town Insurance - St. Augustine

Christopher Jones: We worked with Ralph on our homeowners insurance recently and had a great, hassle free experience. He was very knowledgeable, provided several options, and provided prompt service!

Thompson Baker Agency, Inc. - St. Augustine

Stephanie Cook: I worked with Tracy on an auto insurance policy and had a fabulous experience! She was friendly, prompt, professional and made the experience a smooth and quick one. She was patient with my questions and concerns and made herself readily available via email and phone throughout the process. I couldn’t have asked for a better broker and she left me feeling confident in the policy she worked out for me. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience and would absolutely recommend Thompson Baker and Tracy for any insurance needs.

Christopher Brown - GEICO Insurance Agent - St. Augustine

Melania Atzori: Visited this office today and left very happy. They were able to answer all my questions, and made sure that my needs were met. I left feeling very confident that I was in excellent hands.

Janet Tillman - State Farm Insurance Agent - St. Augustine

nicole favreau: I’ve had an amazing experience with Janet Tillman’s State Farm office! From the moment I reached out, the entire team was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly helpful. They took the time to explain all my options, answered every question with patience, and made sure I had the best coverage for my needs. Janet and her staff truly care about their clients — it feels more like working with family than a business. If you’re looking for top-notch service and peace of mind, this is the office to call. Highly recommended!

GreatFlorida Insurance - Beau Barry - St. Augustine

Jennifer Gamble: I highly recommend Amy Nuttall for home and car insurance. She saved me over $1,000 a year on my home owner’s insurance and hundreds of dollars on my car insurance. She is friendly, dependable and responds promptly with any questions I may have. Choose Great Florida and Amy Nuttall in St. Augustine!

Fender Insurance Agency - St. Augustine

Paul Bohnenkamper: Dayna went above and beyond to find me a great rate with a good company Thanks Dayna!

Perry Unwalla - State Farm Insurance Agent - St. Augustine

Jeanne Ryan: State Farm is the best! I have been a customer ever since I can remember and I have always been pleased with their service. I can call anytime and Mary and Aretha are always very patient in helping me with my needs and questions. I love being able to get on the phone and get immediate assistance with people that I have known for a long time and they know me. Nice being able to put a name and a face together. Very personal service!

Your Florida Insurance Agency LLC - St. Augustine

Eric Emmons: I have no confidence in Michael Mayer as a Farmers Insurance agent or his business practices. His office changed my dwelling coverage from 700k to 545k without letting me know or asking if I would like a change in coverage. His office acted liked they were saving me money but my premium was basically the same with less coverage. I specifically asked his office staff if there was a change in coverage and they said "no" which was a lie. I brought my concerns to him thru email and he responded with a generic reply like I didnt understand how home insurance works. I need a specific amount of dwelling coverage due to the uniqueness of my home, but not once did he offer to ask questions or inquire about why I needed a certain amount of coverage instead unilaterally decreased my coverage without letting me know. If I didnt catch it and had a claim I would be S.O.L. I called farmers corporate and they were appalled with the specifics of my situation. The agent took time to ask why I needed that amount of coverage and thru documentation Farmers insured me for more than 700k dwelling coverage in case of a loss. I switched agents because Farmers is not to blame, Michael Mayer is. I would give zero stars if I could. Stay away!!!!!

Britni Burkins: Allstate Insurance - St. Augustine

Linda and Peter Dytrych: We switched over to Allstate as our premiums had been skyrocketing with our former insurance company. We are not people that want the cheapest insurance nor the cheapest coverages, for sure. We are just looking for fair pricing and an insurance company that will have our best interests and needs. Honestly, we have just purchased an insurance policy for 2 cars, our condo, and umbrella coverage. We sat down with Melissa Whiting and she is wonderful to work with; integrity, fairness, and honesty. Offered us coffee or water, even. Truly a breath of fresh air for the insurance industry. We are just new clients so we cannot comment on how the company will handle any claims. We love the location here in St. Augustine at Nix Boat Yard Road. Beautiful office; all renovated! We are saving about $1,600; we did reduce our umbrella coverage, yet still a very nice lower premium. Allstate offers 6 months only for auto insurance; for condo and umbrella, a full 12 month policy.