Best 12 Diamond & Gold Jewelry Stores in Orlando, FL (part 3)

Nishant Pandya With Americas Best Jewelry Buyer, I had an excellent experience. They provided me with a reasonable offer for my gold jewelry and were honest and competent. The entire process was smooth and stress-free. I’ve been to a few places before, but this one really stood out for their transparency. I’d definitely come back next time I need to sell jewelry.

carla911pr63 I came by 2x and Kim Thank Jewelers was closed. I finally got found the perfect gift I was looking for to give both my daughters. An authentic Jade bangle and ring. Plus a beautiful gold band for the other child. Christine & her Mom (original owner for 40 yrs) helped put on the beautiful Jade. It was a perfect gift of love for both my girls that they can treasure forever. I definitely recommend this store and trust in their quality jewelry. Next year, I will get my Badge necklace for me and a nice bracelet for my grandson. I also got my rings cleaned and the store hours.

Larry Russell Jr A Very Awesome Piece of Jewelry. The craftsmanship in the attention to the details of the lion and the chains that bind it are truly amazing. The ring feels good on my finger and its not too heavy. It is truly a masterfully crafted piece of jewelry. The sizing is perfect for a slightly below average finger. Customer Service is great. Every time I asked a question about the status of my ring, I received an immediate response. It was really great doing business with NightRider and I wouldnt hesitate purchasing more jewelry from them and I highly recommend checking them out. I purchased my second ring from NightRider, and once again, the experience has been exceptional. A special shout-out to Rose at the Orlando location — her professionalism, warmth, and knowledge made the process seamless and enjoyable. If you’re considering a bold, meaningful piece of jewelry that combines artistry with quality, I highly recommend checking out NightRider. You won’t be disappointed.

Cristina Cruz Nelson was very nice and helpful ! And family owned support small businesses !

Meggie Pollifrone Beware of Bellagio Jewelers – Dishonest, unprofessional, and careless! My wedding ring broke in less than a month of wearing it — a diamond had completely fallen out. On July 15th, I brought it to Bellagio Jewelers for repair. They took my ring, gave me a ticket, and even wrote down my phone number incorrectly, which meant I never got a single update. After weeks of me calling and chasing them, they finally told me on August 1st my ring was “ready.” When I went to pick it up, it was immediately clear they had no idea what they were doing. They were completely confused about the insurance coverage I had purchased, and kept calling a so-called “manager” who apparently never works there — and may not even exist. When they finally brought out my ring, I was horrified. Instead of properly repairing it, they had done what looked like a cheap, sloppy patch job. The diamonds looked dusty, cracked, and glued together. Where one of my three rectangle diamonds should have been, they had filled the space with half a broken diamond and a tiny mismatched stone. There was still a gaping hole where the original diamond had fallen out! My ring looked ten times worse after their “repair” than it did before I brought it in. Even the women working in the store admitted the jeweler had done a horrendous job. Instead of owning their mistake and replacing the ring, they tried to upsell me on a brand-new ring and told me I just needed to “pay the difference.” Absolutely unbelievable. Since August 1st, I’ve been told my ring was “sent back to the jeweler,” but I’ve had zero calls or updates. I’ve asked twice to speak to a manager and was told “the manager doesn’t work here” — then the employee quickly backtracked to “he’s not here.” The dishonesty and lack of accountability is shocking. At this point, I have no confidence in Bellagio Jewelers. They are running what feels like a scam, selling low-quality diamonds and providing terrible service. If I don’t hear back immediately, I will have no choice but to report my ring as stolen. Save yourself the money, the stress, and the heartbreak. Do not trust Bellagio Jewelers.

SAMEH Alkhatib As soon as I walked in, I felt nervous alongside my fiancé while searching for the perfect ring for our engagement party. Laila and Maria were there to guide us, explaining everything step-by-step and offering their support. Thank you for making our experience truly fantastic. We appreciate your dedication and the time you spent with us, allowing us to revisit our decision. A heartfelt thank you to Laila and Maria for everything. We are grateful once again.

Angie Acevedo ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Can I give him 10 Starts!! Curtis was absolutely amazing! He was so patient and took the time to really listen and make sure every detail was perfect. My fiancé and I couldn’t be happier with his service. What stood out the most was his patience and care—it’s so rare to experience that nowadays. He made what could have been a very hard decision feel so easy. Once I found the right ring, we both just knew it was the one, and Curtis knew it too. We both said “yes” to our rings with Curtis, and I couldn’t recommend him more. If you’re looking for someone who truly cares and doesn’t make you feel rushed, go see Curtis at Kay’s you won’t regret it. Outstanding customer service!

Angel Stykemain Lots of jewelry selections. Good customer service. I keep coming back. Recommended to people looking for a jewelry store in Orlando.

Alex Bruno Walked in today to have some jewelry appraised. Kash was very welcoming and honest. He warned me against leaving the jewelry since it could take a couple weeks being holiday season. He then cleaned all the jewelry on the house, so I could enjoy a clean look for holidays. Looks like I’ve finally found an honest, reliable local jeweler.

Carlos Cantarey Buying a piece of jewelry here is synonymous with prestige and quality. Its probably because my wife and I are relatively young, and because my wife already knew the pendant I wanted, we walked in asking for it. But if the saleswoman had been friendlier, Im sure she would have gotten us a cross-sale. If we were in the store for 10 minutes, thats a long time. But Im glad she understood my Spanish when I told my wife the chain was short, because (in English) she said she would sell us a longer one, and we gladly bought it.

Aaron Taylor Me and my Fiancé went down to Orlando to get married. I had forgotten to get a wedding band for the wedding and we were scrambling to find one when we stumbled upon Madison’s jeweler’s. The Owner and his Niece were super kind and were able to find a band that matched her engagement ring and resize it for us. They even helped resize mine to the correct size on site 10/10 would recommend!

Hyun Ah Perez Beautiful unique pieces with an incredible staff! I love coming in every time and trying on and designing new pieces. You feel at home and part of the family as soon as you walk in these doors. They listen to your needs, help you design what you want and follow up every step of the way on when your piece will be done and ready for pickup. A true neighborhood gem!