Best 12 Auto Repair Shops Near near Me in Key West, FL (Update 2025)

Shacoya Miller The owner Justin was supposed to repair my rear view mirror but instead broke my front glass. Very unprofessional and showed no empathy for breaking my glass. He did not apologize. Instead he referred me to a glass company trying to make me pay out of pocket for him breaking my front glass window. DO NOT BRING YOUR CAR TO THEM!

Cindy Josin Justin was very kind, taking time to explain exact problem. Charged me only wholesale for hard to find newer Genesis and then a fair price for labor. Hes very very busy but I watched him juggle everything from customers to parts to employees.

Jadranka Marich Took my jeep there . Needed some work on my running boards. Justin the owner was very helpful. Problem resolved. Highly recommend this place

Jeff Wilson Was in the keys for a month and backed into a tree and did some body damage to the bed of my truck. They fixed it in record time so that it didnt hamper my plans here at all. It looks like brand new. The damage was in an area of a body flair and the body work was flawless. Techs did an amazing job with the hammer/dolly as it looks like there is minimal if any filler in the area. Paint/Clearcoat looks amazing and was feathered in without a flaw. Taillight fits back in perfectly and snugley and the supports for it were pretty bent up. Liz was also amazing to work with. Would highly recommend Classic to anyone needing a body shop.

Tammy Torres Everyone was awesome! Excellent customer service especially Elizabeth Perrotti super friendly very professional. Thank you for making a horrible situation great again.

Dane Iseman These guys are the best. I got estimates for an out-of-pocket repair job for a used car Id just purchased. Conch Paint & Body came in several hundred dollars less than the rest, but more importantly, they did exactly what they said theyd do. I made an appointment to bring my car in for two weeks down the road. A week later I checked with them to make sure theyd ordered the parts needed. To my astonishment, theyd had the parts for a couple of days and were ready to go. Too often in Key West there seems to be a somewhat lax attitude about doing what you said youd do. Not these folks. The work was done on time and on budget and I couldnt be happier with the results. Highly recommended.

Steven Hall My check engine light was on, he told me to bring my car in, hooked up the diagnostic computer, told me the problem according to the computer said I would be able to drive to Fort Myers just fine. No charge for his diagnostic check. At a time when he could have had me over a barrel, he was more than fair & honest.

Alameda Girl I had a horrible experience at Richards recently. I brought my car in for an oil change and to find out why the check engine light was on. During the course of the oil change the technician broke off the handle of the drivers side door. They tried to replace the handle and it didnt fit. Meanwhile they never told me why I didnt get my car back. I finally went over in person after 4 days and found out what happened. They said the door handles they bought didnt work and Id have to buy another handle myself somewhere. They wouldnt give me my car back unless I paid for the oil change. Meanwhile the check engine light is still on. Dont go to them!

Alonzo Jones After being recommended by a coworker, I went by one day, he gave me a time to come back, and within a reasonable amount of time my car was finished! For all that I had asked of him, he went another further and took care of something else that I didnt realize that needed attention!!!

Terapixel 007 Great service on short notice! We came down to key west for a mini vacation and our AC went out. The owner penciled us in, even though he was fully booked and closed on the weekends. This place is spot on and the owner Mike is very professional and courteous. He also suggested great places to grab a bite to eat!! Well done! Priced really well for a short notice mechanical fix!

Beltz Rosanne (BeltzBusters) From out of town. Had trouble with misfire in engine. Talked to Mike, and he diagnosed the problem, and repaired it. Got car back the same day. Honest pricing. Fast, helpful and experienced mechanic. Wouldnt hesitate to go back, and if lived here would be our shop for all cars! ...and the hubby loves the name too! Highly recommend. Would give Oilys 10 stars if we could.

Goldstein David (BocaDavie) Original date of service: October 29, 2015. Total cost of repairs: $598. When we arrived in Key West for the annual Fantasy Fest celebration two indicator lights activated on the dash.Oilys was one of the top rated auto service facilities, so I brought the vehicle there. They had several vehicles waiting for service, but Mike said he would do what he could to help me out. Within minutes he brought my car to the service bay and did a diagnosis, revealing a bad oil leak that ruined the alternator. Despite being backed up with work he said he would fit my car in (although a new alternator did need to be sent in from Miami, so the car had to be kept overnight). Within 24 hours the car was repaired and working perfectly. He also discovered a smaller leak from a valve cover gasket and wrote up an estimate to repair that (the gasket repair could not be completed in the time I had; we needed to head home the next day). Overall I was extremely pleased with the service and the facility. Its one of those places that doesnt look like much from the outside (though its decor does fit in with the laid-back Key West style), but the guys inside really know their stuff. Mike went out of his way to get my work done, despite already being extremely busy with other work (about 70,000 people come down for Fantasy Fest; Im sure it generates more than its share of business for the area). I will return to Oilys in the future when I need auto service in Key West, great job!

shane farmer Fast, reliable and professional. I highly recommend using the shop over all the others in Key West. This place was recommended by friends for being the best body shop in Key West. I had recent body work done with them and everything was on point. The truck is back to looking new again and everything looks great. Dropped it off late on a Monday and they had it done by the following Tuesday. Rear quarter panel damage and tailgate damage.

Taras Romanchuk I want to take a moment to express my disappointment in this place. This is my second time using their services (first wasnt too bad). I had my vehicle there for a dent repair and when I came back to pick up the vehicle, it was a complete mess. The owner, Tommy, seemed to be a nice guy, but when I pointed out to the dirth and scratches all over the drivers seat, dashboard, steering wheel, door panels and other parts of the vehicle, he said "i cant make it look like a new car, because its not a new car". First of all, its a 2024 vehicle and it came to your service in a perfect clean condition, so I expect to pick it up the same condition. He didnt want to listen, interrupting me all the time saying "if you dont like our services, you don’t have to use us again..." i will certainly not going, Tommy, and do not recommend anyone in the Keys using your services till you improve your customer service. Using cheap plastic to cover vehicle interior is essential, i had to spend another 1.5 hours to clean it up after you. The fuel lid was scratched somehow and he agreed to repaint it... but man, I could do it better not being an owner of a body shop (there are traces of dust on a paint). The dent was fixed 3 out of 5*, so this review gets 2* not 1*. Good luck!

Matthew Reed They did a great job fixing my car. They kept me up to date with the repair and it was washed right before I picked it up. I had an unrelated rattle and Tommy spent over an hour troubleshooting the source of the noise and eventually fixed it. He definitely went above and beyond to help me out. I’ll definitely be using them in the future.

Niveen F. Elwerr Ive always had positive experiences here. Everyone is very helpful. Sales team are super friendly (thank you Fernando) Chad is my service advisor, and he is very knowledgeable and professional. Im grateful for all your help

jeremy tetrault I can’t say enough great things about Keys Auto Center — this place is a total game-changer when it comes to car buying and service. From the moment I walked in, the experience was seamless, professional, and actually enjoyable (yes, enjoyable at a car dealership!). Lee Holt was incredibly knowledgeable and made sure I felt confident every step of the way. Stephen Bender brought a level of integrity and friendliness that’s rare in the industry — I could tell he genuinely cared about finding the right fit for me. Michael Pantalone handled everything with precision and professionalism, making the process smooth from financing to paperwork. And Anthony Lazarus? Absolute legend — he went above and beyond to ensure I was completely satisfied and even followed up afterward to make sure everything was perfect. This team doesn’t just sell cars — they build relationships. If you’re looking for quality vehicles, unmatched service, and a crew that truly has your back, Keys Auto Center is the only place to go. Thank you, Lee, Stephen, Michael, and Anthony — you’ve got a customer for life.

Yoel Avila The biggest disappointment I have with a dealer is this one in Key West. After a week, they managed to find something simple, and because I had already explained it several times, they dont listen to the customer, and when it comes to trying to raise issues they dont have, I suggest they be more professional. Thanks to Caridad, whose immense patience allowed me to get someone to listen to me.

JMV All the tools and help you need to get it done.

Ruben Centeno Very friendly staff, if you’re military I recommend coming here for working on car issues.

marcus buff Art and the rest of his guys are awesome. Always willing to help and make sure youre getting your vehicle fixed right.

Jamee Smith Our trucks AC decided to quit working in this 100 degree heat wave. We called & got an appointment the very next morning. Very thankful it was just the Freon & not something more serious. The truck was fixed quickly & we couldn’t be more grateful.

John Parce Meticulous body and paint work large and small. OEM parts. Hard working and fair pricing.

Danny Delarosa Outstanding service from phone to service! Fast knowledgable and friendly !!!! Top Notch mechanic! I recommend them for all your service needs! Will use again when the next opportunity arises and we know as boat owners we will need them again!!!

Chris Cullen Mobile Marine Services was extremely responsive. They reached out to me on a Sunday, even though they were closed and outside their normal business hours. I was stuck at a dock in Key West and they serviced my boat right at the slip. They were highly professional and I would use them again.

Thomas Curry I originally hired Key West Engine Service to work on my boat. I waited over 2 weeks and woke up to an email “Sorry. We are too busy to come do your work.” The guys at the marina recommended I call Matt at Mobile Marine and they were out the next morning! The mechanics very very professional and courteous. I will use them every time now.

Zoey miller The entire team at Keys Auto Center is outstanding! From start to finish, they kept me informed every step of the way while my car was in the shop. They were always available to answer my questions and made the whole process smooth and stress-free. Most of my communication was through Regina, who provided me nothing but top-notch service. I highly recommend Keys Auto Center!

Rodney Smith I am very happy with the way Keys Auto Center helped us with our Jeep. I had a on going problem with my Gladiator, I had taking it to a different dealership three times and the engine light would still come on after a few miles driving. Key Auto took my Jeep on two long test drive to make sure the problem was resolved. Thanks Sharon Wager for being professional!!

Michael Kayner My service advisor Regina was very personable, easy to reach by phone and accommodating for my service needs on my 2023 Ram 3500 I purchased from them. I would highly recommend getting your vehicle serviced at Keys Auto Center. I had my fuel filters changed, oil changed and new tires installed! Thank you Regina & team!

G Patte While camping in Key West, needed to do general maintenance on our generator. The lady at the counter was very knowledgeable and helpful. Order supplies 3 times while here. Excellent service!

Antares Zn What a great company! We pulled into Stock Island Marina with a blown out raw water pump on our John Deere auxiliary engine. I gave them a call and the service manager John had a tech down to us early the next morning. Celeste had the part in stock so the tech, Bob, returned the following morning to install it in plenty of time for us to make our planned departure. They were all very courteous, friendly and efficient. Many thanks to John, Celeste and Bob for taking such great care of us! Captain Geoff Gardner M.Y. Great Adventure Nordhavn 68

Diesel Mike Chris is very experienced and very professional

Gus Amazing service and great value. They changed my battery and oil within two hours. Highly recommended.

Denise Hoagland Thank you Steve! We are so grateful to Steve for checking out our van before we took a 1500 mile trip home. Check engine lights came on while on our way down, transmission making noises. KW Dealership gave us a date to just check the codes a month away. So kind to take the time and his efficiency in explaining the situation was detailed. Highly recommended this authentic mechanic!

Rubi Belotti I had an excellent experience with shifting gears automotive! My car was having some issues, and they quickly diagnosed the problem, explained everything clearly, and got it fixed in one day. The staff was professional, friendly, and really went above and beyond to make sure I understood the repairs. The quality of work was top-notch, and the pricing was fair. I’m so relieved to have my car back in great shape, and I highly recommend this shop to anyone needing reliable and trustworthy service!