florida Date: 09-18-2025

Top 14 Rated Jeweler in Stuart, FL (part 2)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1Treasure Coast Jewelers41-B SW Osceola St, Stuart, FL 34994
2Island Cotton Company53 SW Flagler Ave, Stuart, FL 34994
3Anthonys Fine Jewelry1286 NW Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994
4Condon Jewelers850 NW Federal Hwy Suite 231, Stuart, FL 34994
5Wild Side Pawn and Jewelry4260 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997
6Diamonds By Terry3868 SE Dixie Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997
7John David Cooney577 SE Central Pkwy, Stuart, FL 34994
8Gumbo Limbo Gifts37 SW Osceola St, Stuart, FL 34994
9Beryl & Co Jewelers888 S Colorado Ave Suite #A, Stuart, FL 34994
10Just Gold Jewelers2691 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34996
11Pirate Firearms, Jewelry, and Pawn2201 Southeast Indian Street, Suite E2, Stuart, FL 34997
12Josephs Jewelry Stuart5250 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997
13Colorado Pawn and Jewelry2275 S Kanner Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994
14Flagler Jewelry & Gifts37 SW Flagler Ave, Stuart, FL 34994

1.Treasure Coast Jewelers

Address: 41-B SW Osceola St, Stuart, FL 34994

(2) user ratings total:

Anne zeller Wonderful store!!!!
5 /5

2.Island Cotton Company

Address: 53 SW Flagler Ave, Stuart, FL 34994

(19) user ratings total:

E. M.M. Had your employee not yelled at my wife for using the the bathroom half an hour after we shopped there we would not have returned the garbage we bought from you. Enjoy selling fairy hair.
1 /5

3.Anthonys Fine Jewelry

Address: 1286 NW Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994

(15) user ratings total:

Bob McAnnally Went to Anthonys to have one platinum ring repaired and a family heirloom gold & diamond ring restored. Moses did an outstanding job and the rings came out beautiful. I would highly recommend Anthonys for all your jewelry needs.
5 /5

4.Condon Jewelers

Address: 850 NW Federal Hwy Suite 231, Stuart, FL 34994

(14) user ratings total:

Charles Housner Second time for a jewelry repair. Todd handles jewelry repair and Dinah and staff work with the customers. Todds work is superior; and, Dinah and her staff are cordial and customer centric. This jeweler provides good value and good customer service. I recommend them. 9/27/16 I continue to patronize this shop for repairs and service. They are top notch...easy to work with, their prices are fair, and they provide excellent value. You can trust them with you most valuable jewelry. I highly recommend them.
5 /5

5.Wild Side Pawn and Jewelry

Address: 4260 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997

(1379) user ratings total:

Garrett Garcia I have bought and sold multiple items here. The staff are very friendly and are always helpful! I have never had a problem here, and they definitely have my business for the long run!
5 /5

6.Diamonds By Terry

Address: 3868 SE Dixie Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997

(13) user ratings total:

Lucie Kleinman BUYER BE WARE! Brought two pieces in to have clasps repaired, replaced or secured. I had not worn them in a while and just wanted to sure it was safe to start wearing without fear of a laps failing. I was told they would need to be replaced. One for a a gold bracelet the other a non gold chain. I was charged $95 for one and $65 for the other. When I asked why so much I was told “because gold is expensive”. When I asked for my original clasps to be returned, given the high price of gold I figured I may as well collect my property, I was told I would be charged more as it was a given that I had “traded” my old clasp for the new. I was stunned, but said I’d buy back my old clasp anyway. I suspected they would not be able to produce it as it had not been changed. I was charged $11.00 for an old “gold” clasp. So, basically the part was $11.00 and I paid $84 plus tax for labor (to attach clasp to chain.) The returned clasp was not my original clasp. It was much larger, broken and a different shape and color. And my bracelet had the same old clasp I had for years, it had not in fact been replaced. The “new “ claps was visibly worn and scratched. It was not replaced as the owner indicated and the charge reflected.by I was honestly too stunned by the brazen thievery to articulate my concerns. This place is 100% a rip off. What a miserable way to steal from trusting customer. The entire experience left me wondering if I’d ever be able to trust a jeweler ever again. Do not make the same mistake. Find another jeweler.
1 /5

7.John David Cooney

Address: 577 SE Central Pkwy, Stuart, FL 34994

(13) user ratings total:

Ami Shelton Our family has been so blessed by Mr. Cooney’s talent. We asked him to set a diamond that my mother had given to my daughter into a gorgeous leaf engagement setting. Mr. Cooney sent us videos and pictures during each stage of the creation process. This made our experience even more personal and special. A few months later we requested he place my engagement diamond into a pendant that had the same details as the engagement setting. The result exceeded our expectations in every way. I must admit I was brought to tears when I first saw his creation. Not only have my daughter, myself, my husband and my parents been blessed by Mr. Cooney, but so will generations to come by the heirlooms we will pass down to them.
5 /5

8.Gumbo Limbo Gifts

Address: 37 SW Osceola St, Stuart, FL 34994

(13) user ratings total:

Valarie Sadusky Gumbo Limbo Gifts is one of the finest stores in downtown Stuart. The owner and her employees are angels! I left my purse outside the store and the employees noticed it and made the effort to find my phone number and contact me. I can’t be more appreciative. Please support the downtown local businesses, they are truly great people!
5 /5

9.Beryl & Co Jewelers

Address: 888 S Colorado Ave Suite #A, Stuart, FL 34994

(129) user ratings total:

Katheryne Chester I highly recommend this jewelry store. I brought in 3 watches to be cleaned and serviced. I was figuring it would take at least 3-4 days. I was shocked when all 3 were ready within 24 hours. Batteries replaced and completely cleaned and buffed out. They are super friendly and family owned. I believe in supporting local small businesses and Beryl & Co has gained my trust and future business.
5 /5

10.Just Gold Jewelers

Address: 2691 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34996

images Just Gold Jewelers

(12) user ratings total:

Wild Eyed Photography My husband and I visited Just Gold Jewelers today to have them repair my engagement ring after it was caught on my finger and pretty majorly bent. This family was so sweet and helpful, they even cleaned as well! They were friendly and welcoming and their beautiful workmanship blew us both away. My ring hasnt looked this beautiful since the day my husband proposed! They are the BEST!
5 /5

11.Pirate Firearms, Jewelry, and Pawn

Address: 2201 Southeast Indian Street, Suite E2, Stuart, FL 34997

(109) user ratings total:

Chris F The owner and all his employees know their stuff. Give great advice and have great prices. Tremendous inventory of high quality items. Highly recommended. I drive from Delray Beach to this place cause it’s the best in Florida.
5 /5

12.Josephs Jewelry Stuart

Address: 5250 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997

(1022) user ratings total:

Cheryl Kate Hohweiler Brian, Michelle and Vanessa were amazing and so helpful. Not to mention super quick in fixing two watches for me in a pinch! Never had an unpleasant experience with Joseph’s! The best around in merchandise selection and customer service is top notch!
5 /5

13.Colorado Pawn and Jewelry

Address: 2275 S Kanner Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994

(1007) user ratings total:

jav riv This pawn shop was great, clean and the staff was awesome. A lot of cool things in store at really great prices. I went to sell something, ended up buying something and getting a better deal then what the tag originally was. Blaine was helpful, knowledgeable and really sympathetic. By far the best pawn shop I’ve been too!!! Ask for Blaine,real welcoming and down to earth guy!!
5 /5

14.Flagler Jewelry & Gifts

Address: 37 SW Flagler Ave, Stuart, FL 34994

(1) user ratings total:

Happy CG This store sells vintage and antique jewelry, dinnerware, decorations, furniture, and more. The prices are excellent and everything is one of a kind. The owner Jim is very friendly and interacts with his customers in a way that really made me feel at home. His prices are fair and all his items are in excellent shape. He really has a passion for what he sells, you can tell in the way he lovingly tells you about his items and where he got everything. He loves to travel around the world and pick up unique places. My mom and I got two beautiful and classic vintage rings, hers has an opal and mine an amethyst. I would definitely come back again.
5 /5