List 17 Auto Services , Car Repair near St. Augustine, FL (Part 2)

Craige Ohlstein If you value your car, do not bring it to this location. I had a flat tire on my way down to Florida visiting my dad and had tire rack. Send this location a replacement tire. I scheduled an appointment and came in and had the tire changed while dropping off the car I instructed this location not to over torque my wheels as they were a special set. The technician then torque to my wheels to 168 foot pounds and stripped three out of my five lugs. They also billed me for changing a valve stem which they did not do. Once I returned home, I was having an issue with the same wheel that they worked on and I decided to try to take it off to see if there was an issue. Upon doing so I noticed the three stripped lugs as well as the damage done to my wheel. I called and try to have a conversation with the manager Donnie and all he tried to do was skate the issue instead of trying to resolve the problem. Now I’m stuck with a $500 bill due to having the lugs drilled off of my car while the wheel was still attached. If you value your car and the way, it is treated do not under any circumstances go to the store.

Bryan Mendez I recently had all four tires replaced and got an alignment done at Firestone Complete Auto Care, and I couldn’t be happier with the service. From start to finish, the team was professional, honest, and efficient. They took the time to explain my options and helped me choose the best tires for my car and budget. What really impressed me was the deal they offered — I got a great price on a full set of quality tires and the alignment was included at a competitive rate. Everything was done quicker than expected, and my car drives smoother than ever. Highly recommend Firestone if you’re looking for solid work, fair pricing, and peace of mind. I’ll definitely be coming back for any future maintenance!

Ozgur Ozanguc Maybe the last HONEST true AMERICAN mechanic here. Mr. Ken helped us immensely and fixed the car in no time and at a very good price. I would drive 4 hours back to get my car fixed again by him. Do not look further. This is THE mechanic you are looking for.

Helena Chase I purchased a Toyota Pre- Runner 2000 from Family Kia (St Augustine)- left them a positive review. I was just about to edit that review. I believe it’s likely more worthwhile to give credit due- my truck runs reliably after service provided post purchase due to Mr.McGuire. I had not owned the used truck for an entire week before check engine alert. The dealer (rather than take a look themselves) sent me his direction. I’m aware “as is” -but not even 7 days from-a “family dealer”. All worth it in the end- You are much luckier to know the fixer than the seller, I guess! I also discovered a great seafood market (Kyle’s) with produce stand and bakery- right around the corner, I would not yet have known existed. All kinds of treasures around his neck of the woods - I’ll take it as a blessing in disguise! This was back in April- catching up on sending my Thank You note.

James Heritage Fast and reliable sey

Sabrina Cheap work with good prices

Gail Rockwood The guy that came out to jump my black 2005 monte carlo was the sweetest. He also gave me great advice. Thanks from Candy.

Betty Ann White Hard working, good people. Rico is the best.

Jay Listed I cannot say enough good things about Nate and the entire staff at Evans Automotive. I have a vehicle with 26 inch rims and finding good tires seems to be very difficult. After an insanely bad experience with a tire shop in Jacksonville, Nate and the team at Evans went above and beyond to help me get my vehicle situated. They thoroughly made sure I was pleased with the ride and continued to check up to make sure everything was still good, well after the install. As long as Im living in St Augustine, I will not take any of my vehicles anywhere else.

Jess C. I truly cannot say enough good things about Evans, and in particular the manager, Nate. Top notch work, fair prices, excellent customer service. We were in a really tough situation and Nate went way above and beyond what he needed to do to help us out. Its hard to find such quality and integrity these days. Highly, highly recommend Evans for anything car related!

Ty Lee Had an issue with my drive shaft and needed the U-joint ring replaced. This mechanic came out quickly, diagnosed the problem on the spot, and got it fixed fast and right the first time. Super knowledgeable, came fully prepared, and didn’t try to upsell anything unnecessary. You can tell he takes pride in his work. Fair pricing too. If you need someone reliable and honest who actually knows what they’re doing—this is your guy. Highly recommend!

Shawn dobry Ian was fantastic!! A reliable and honest mechanic, something rare to find these days. Was able to diagnose and fix my truck and was able to get out to me very quickly. Communication was great and he responded fast. He also provided me pictures of what was wrong and kept me updated with a timeline of events. Pricing is also very competitive and reasonable, won’t find anything better or faster around town. Definitely keeping his number saved in my phone and already plan to use his services again!!

Howard Becker Shane is an honest man and that’s saying something in this crazy world. Awesome mechanic and best service in the area! Always a great price and excellent work. My friends and family have always brought their vehicles here to be worked on We won’t go anywhere else.

Stéphane Dechaine Long story short, I put 18 gallons of gas in a diesel tank and drove 1 hour. I know. Broke down in St Augustine 8 days away from taking the plane back home. I met someone who introduced me to Shane and I couldn’t have been in greater hands. Not only did he take me on short notice but he also saved my engine and saved me a lot of money. Very competent and kind team. 10/10 would recommend. These folks deserve work.

Torei S Mike in sales was an unexpected gift I didnt know I needed. From the moment I made an inquiry online to the moment it arrived at my door 3 days later, the service was exceptional. At the last moment, my pre-approval fell thru and I thought I would have to wait to get a vehicle BUT Mike and Ed in finance worked a literal miracle that still let me leave with exactly what I wanted. I didnt settle so neither should u! Go holla at my boy Mike!

John Rooney During my recent service visit, I was truly inspired by the exceptional customer service from Service Advisor Tunde O’Connor. She welcomed me with open arms as soon as I approached her desk. She kept me informed throughout the service on my car. Once the service was complete, she personally walked me to my vehicle, noticing some wet spots from the car wash, and began drying them off without me saying a word. I have never experienced such VIP treatment at any car dealership. Please convey my heartfelt appreciation.

Ed Martin Took my diesel E350 passenger van to Melvins for a new radiator and AC work. It was done in a reasonable amount of time. Great communication from them throughout, as to the issues and my options so we were all on the same page. I will definitely look to Melvins for repairs moving forward!!

Wendy Kissinger Melvins got my high roof Ram promaster van in for a transmission fluid flush service within a couple days, competed the work fast and charged much less than the estimate I had received. Very fair price, fast and efficient service, and super friendly staff. Ill definitely take my van in again for future maintenance and repair needs. Thanks, Mark!

DAYANAND Maharaj Excellent and professional service from owner Shaun Tipton, Will and all mechanics at Velocity. They solve any technical issues and stand by their work. Velocity commissioned a full rebuild of my 2006 Porsche Cayman S. Engine increased from a 3.4L to 3.8L. The rebuilt engine in now bulletproof. I highly recommend! I had my second oil change after engine rebuild. The engine is powerful and perfect. My car is turning heads! I am a Velocity customer for life.

Nulita Loder Very professional, organized and friendly. Everything was expliained with great attention to detail. I felt like they are trustworthy and good at what they do. Great experience with these guys, I will definately be taking my car to them for future repairs.

Duane Fogle Honest, Reliable, and Skilled – Rays Commercial is the Real Deal! Ray’s Commercial on Main Street is hands down one of the best auto shops I’ve ever been to. If youre looking for honest work, fair pricing, and real expertise, this is the place. Ray and his team know their stuff and treat every customer like family. They don’t try to upsell you on things you don’t need. Instead, they explain the issue clearly, give you real options, and always stand by their work. Whether it’s routine maintenance or something major, I’ve always left feeling confident that my vehicle was in the best hands. The shop is clean, well-run, and fast without cutting corners. You can tell they take pride in what they do—and it shows in every repair. If youre tired of overpriced dealerships and shady mechanics, give Ray’s Commercial a try. It’s rare to find a place with this level of trust, transparency, and quality. Five stars isn’t enough!

Mark Wallace ⭐ One Star: Rays Commercial Main St. Auto – Where the Cats Outnumber the Ethics (and the Prices are Criminal) Let me tell you, stepping into Rays Commercial Main St. Auto in St. Augustine was an experience. My first clue should have been the cat food adorning the entrance – a preview of the feral pricing practices within. Walk through the door and youre greeted not by a friendly mechanic, but by a feline monarch perched regally on the counter, surveying its domain. Frankly, I think the cat was the most competent being there. Then, your eyes drift left, and thats when the "mechanic shop" facade truly crumbles. Fox News blaring, a giant Trump flag dominating the wall... it was a glaring red flag waving in my face, and I, foolishly, ignored it. I should have turned tail right then and there, because what followed was less a repair service and more a highway robbery with a wrench. The markup on parts? Youd think they were custom-forged from solid gold at the bottom of the Mariana Trench and flown in via private jet. A Duralast turn signal switch for $15.99? They charged me a cool $300 for it. A rear taillight at $161? And the labor for that single taillight? A mind-boggling $500. Seriously, did they dismantle the entire vehicle to swap a bulb? The fuel pump at $346 seemed almost reasonable until the $525 labor charge punched me in the gut. And lets not forget the "quality" of their work. They zip-tied wiring under the frame, a hack job that, predictably, worked itself loose and came apart within a mere two months. Their guarantee? Non-existent. Everything they touched lasted about as long as a New Years resolution. Its clear they have no faith in their own shoddy repairs, and neither should you. The invoice itself is a work of abstract art – jumbled, impenetrable, and utterly impossible to reconcile. Its almost as if they designed it to obscure the egregious overcharges, hoping youd give up trying to decipher their cryptic mathematics. To summarize, if youre looking for a mechanic shop where "customer service" means a cat on the counter, the news is aggressively partisan, the prices are so inflated they belong in an airport gift shop, and their repairs fall apart faster than a house of cards, then Rays Commercial Main St. Auto is your spot. For the rest of us, its a sad, comical testament to what happens when "Trump Humpers" are given an invoice pad and a calculator. Save your money, your sanity, and your dignity – go literally anywhere else.

Hannah Arendt What a great couple of guys! We drove to FL from WI and had the alternator go out as we got into St Augustine. We called and ,first of all, these were the first mobile mechanics to answer and say they would help. They went to AutoZone, arranged to have us pay for a new alternator and then rolled up and replaced it in 30 min. Super nice, smiling the whole time. Very professional. Wonderful experience! We were beyond impressed. I wish I could give them 12/5 stars!

Caitlin Town I called around 10am on a Saturday, sent Ian my address. He said it would take a couple of hours to get there. Never showed up, never heard back. The oil is leaking out of my car, and I will have to take an unpaid day off work to get it fixed because I relied on mobile mechanics.

Ray Crosby Scheduled an apt ant 8 am yesterday for a transmission flush. Told it would take a few hours at 4 pm they called to tell me they completed an inspection of the vehicle and wanted to tell me what all was wrong with vehicle. Informed them I just needed the transmission flushed. Asked why is they took it upon themselves to inspect my vehicle. They stated we check every vehicle for free. No way in hell is someone checking a vehicle for free first off. Second they never completed the transmission flush. Told them I only wanted this service and to get it done. Was told it would be ready for 8 am this morning. I arrived and it still wasn’t done. The shop guy says we tried to call you and you didn’t answer. No I answered but I told you to only change the transmission fluid. Needless to say don’t waste your time like I did. This place is a scam be very aware. They lie and will tell you, you need things you do not. What a worthless shop and a waste of my time.

Prashanta Pradhan AAMCO did a wonderful job on my car. They were fast, reliable, and true to their word. Matt was especially polite and honest, and his team delivered exactly what they promised. It’s rare to find that level of professionalism and integrity. I’ll definitely be going back, and I 100% recommend them to anyone looking for quality service.

Ken Shipp Finding a great mechanic is difficult these days. Both Sebastian and Omar are top notch people and its a pleasure doing business there knowing youll get great and honest service. Thanks guys!

William Robinson Love these Guys! Sebastian and Omar are respectable, honest (and friendly) mechanics in a small shop, with home town appeal. I drive forty minutes out of my way just to go see them!

Gaurav Nayak Stopped by to get rusted and stuck license plate screws removed. Dave and his team were really helpful in resolving the situation. Highly recommend the customer service here and helpfulness of the staff. Friendly services like this go a long way in growing a strong loyal customer base.

Dana Wilkinson This company “ Crash Champions “ are the BEST!!! Hands down. John and Vince was very professional and fixed my car beyond my expectations, beautiful work and went over and beyond, plugged my tire that had a long nail in it. Crash Champions had my car complete within a week! This company gets five stars⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️‼️

Rock E Quick and reliable

Hector Sosa responsible, recommended

Tiffany Carnes This place delivered for me(and my car). Took it in knowing it needed some work and dreading the process and what Id be quoted - who wants to spend money on car repairs? They gave me a fair price for the work it needed. My son is a mechanic and said the price was fair for all the work it needed. These guys are honest and genuine. I would highly recommend George and his team if you want to feel comfortable with the work on your car. I will be returning if and when I need work done. Thank you guys!!

Gabriel Smith I have followed Toni to this store after his transfer, He has always had the answers i needed when it comes to my car. He is quick and stays on the shop guys to get me in and out and ive even seen him out there doing services himself! (He was a tech for years before moving to the office) just found out he is also bilingual, talk about someone who needs a raise! As long as Toni is in the business, he has a forever customer!